lol, i thought you'd say something like that.
It had to be said because that incident was very dangerous, made more so because to get to the consumer unit a heavy settee had to be moved.
Fair enough, forewarned is forearmed.
A chip pan fire with the controls above the hobs has happened to a friend.
chip pan? do people still use them? maybe a contender for the most dangerous appliance/utensil in the kitchen? If i had one, id be more concerned about where my fire blankets and extinguishers were, not my switches.
If the same chip pan fire happened over a gas hob, how would the problem have been dealt with then?
I still say that it is perfectly acceptable to place a switch inside a cupboard.
If the customer is happy after being told the possibly effects of having the switch not easily accessible then perhaps it could be acceptable.
Id argue whether having the switch inside the adjacent cupboard, top and front is any less accessible than a switch mounted over work tops then obscured by microwaves, pasta/tea/coffee/sugar jugs, mug trees (chip pans
) etc
Id further add that some might argue that the average cooker switch is not even suitable as a device for emergency switching, although there does seem to be a contradiction of sorts between the suggestions of table 53.2 and 537.4.2.6
If it removes the power from an overheating or otherwise dangerous appliance then it serves the purpose.
Ah, its not fair to say that - thats too much like common sense, and we all know that has no place when we are dealing with the regs
I know what you mean and i agree with the spirit of that, but in terms of the regs, i can see scenario where the switch would be acceptable as an emergency switch and also where it would not.
What do you think to the possible contradiction i mentioned above?
Heres another thought, along a similar theme:-
If a cooker switch is suitable to be used as an emergency switch, then i would say so is the main switch in the CU ( as it fits the same criteria)
and it is decided that it is not permissable to fit a cooker switch inside a cupboard.
Does that make any CU installed in a cupboard (or behind heavy settee)non-compliant?
Whats your opinion of FCU's in airing cupboards?
One last thought before i go baste my mind in alcohol -
Whenever this debate comes up and a have another look through section 537, i can't help but think the authors of the emergency switching bit were referring to mainly industrial applications and didn't really have a cooking-related emergency in the forefront of their mind. IMO thats why domestic sparks wrestle with this part of the big red joke book