Noise restriction in Planning Permission
- Thread starter plasterman42
- Start date
Sponsored Links
Conditions are site and work specific. Typically these are applied for several reasons and you may not get to know why as it could be either policy related or subjective based on things like a neighbour has notified the planners of a particular impact the work may make, or the type of work and likely methods of construction, or a new policy or many things. This type of condition is very easy to prove reasonable, and you can't say "the bloke up the road didn't have one so I don't want one"
If you weren't happy with the condition, you should have formally appealed within the time limits. Or submit a section 73 application to remove or amend it.
My apologies:
I had interpreted this as the OP saying could they do DIY in general at other times, not necessarily in relation to the extension to which the condition applies.
The planning condition doesnt constitute a restrictive covenent on the property......so it doesnt apply to other DIY works.
The planning condition is not just noise, but also to restrict site traffic -nobody wants half a dozen builders rocking up a 8.am on a Sunday.
But nobody is going to worry about quiet works being done by you at other times, who will know?
Why stir things up with the council?
It's really a minor condition and as Woody said is "should" and not "must" or "shall"; inspectors will often strike down badly-worded conditions on appeal, but it's not really worth appealing that condition.
In practice, are you neighbours likely to complain if you worked a little beyond the hours stipulated? Is the council likely to follow up, and would they say you are in breach therefore your planning permission is void?? Hardly.
Most neighbours don't particularly like construction noise, but are aware that it doesn't go on for ever, unlike aircraft- or train noise.
Sponsored Links
More likely that some neighbour has objected to the planning application on account of the potential noise, and the planning officer has added the condition just to shut the neighbour up, without really taking the condition too seriously.Maybe the council know that you are a noisy 8ASTARD!
Andy
L
Leofric
This is a common sort of planning consent condition , although usually for bigger jobs I would say ,but I don't see any ambiguity in this condition, it means exactly what it says , and in plain English.
ps
-exactly , builders and sub contractors vans parking outside the property.
It is clear what it means - or maybe it should have said 'thou shalt not etc,etc '.
Last edited by a moderator:
You know what they mean, I know what they mean, the council knows what it means.This is a common sort of planning consent condition , although usually for bigger jobs I would say ,but I don't see any ambiguity in this condition, it means exactly what it says , and in plain English.
ps
-exactly , builders and sub contractors vans parking outside the property.
It is clear what it means - or maybe it should have said 'thou shalt not etc,etc '.
But in the world of the courts, statutory interpretation requires more precision than this when dealing with a condition which potentially
restricts the appellant, and 'should' could be struck down as it is suggestive of advice rather than the more precise 'must' or 'shall'.
We can babble on and use whatever words we like and know what we mean, but in law and contracts each word has specific meaning, and even punctuation can alter the context of a whole sentance.It is clear what it means - or maybe it should have said 'thou shalt not etc,etc '.
- Joined
- 21 Jul 2019
- Messages
- 8
- Reaction score
- 0
- Country
update
I called the planning officer and she said whether it's specified or not all permissions are bound by it, so within reason you can work but if your noisy and get complaints they can stop you, but you DIYers fill ya boots
I called the planning officer and she said whether it's specified or not all permissions are bound by it, so within reason you can work but if your noisy and get complaints they can stop you, but you DIYers fill ya boots
- Joined
- 22 Jul 2016
- Messages
- 5,875
- Reaction score
- 1,081
- Country
The house adjoining me had builders 7 days a week from 7.30 am to gone 8pm
It was a nightmare. They used mini diggers and kangos and one night they built a garden fence using head torches at 10pm . It was a close boated fence so every slat was hammered in by hand.
It was a nightmare. They used mini diggers and kangos and one night they built a garden fence using head torches at 10pm . It was a close boated fence so every slat was hammered in by hand.
L
Leofric
never heard that before, so all permissions are bound by a condition that isn't specified My neighbour has the same condition, though his is a must rather than a shall. His permission also says breaking the condition invalidates the permission. He's broken that condition and several others, including varying levels within root protection zones, digging out roots of protected trees, not protecting trees with scaffolding. He's supposed to have a scheme in place so neighbours can raise concerns as well because the Council know he's a complete arse.
The practical reality is that despite all of that being evidenced to the Council and their tree officer confirming that the various tree conditions have been breached, leading to the Statutory position that the permission is no longer valid, the Council couldn't care less when their options are siding with one party that has a formal right of appeal or the other that can only enforce their rights via a Judicial Review.
You'll find that if you bother the neighbours too much the Council will huff and puff, but they won't actually do anything of any practical consequence to you.
The practical reality is that despite all of that being evidenced to the Council and their tree officer confirming that the various tree conditions have been breached, leading to the Statutory position that the permission is no longer valid, the Council couldn't care less when their options are siding with one party that has a formal right of appeal or the other that can only enforce their rights via a Judicial Review.
You'll find that if you bother the neighbours too much the Council will huff and puff, but they won't actually do anything of any practical consequence to you.
DIYnot Local
Staff member
If you need to find a tradesperson to get your job done, please try our local search below, or if you are doing it yourself you can find suppliers local to you.
Select the supplier or trade you require, enter your location to begin your search.
Are you a trade or supplier? You can create your listing free at DIYnot Local
Sponsored Links
Similar threads
