Is there a tool to permanently lock MCB in On position?

As others have said use a lockable lid/cover/cupboard
Unless the key is immediately available (e.g. in a 'break glass' enclosure) I can't see that is any 'safer' than locking an MCB 'on' if there is no other (accessible) way of killing the circuit - and, as I've just written, the existence of 'another way' really makes a nonsense of the whole exercise.

Kind Regards, John
 
Sponsored Links
I know you can't via the switch, but I assumed, perhaps incorrectly the OP wanted to prevent the MCB from operating ...
If he did want that (which I doubt) then, for pretty obvious reasons, he would be out of luck!

Kind Regards, John
 
If he did want that (which I doubt) then, for pretty obvious reasons, he would be out of luck!

Kind Regards, John
The Crabtree C50 range could be held on, one of the theatres I worked in had a 30A 3ph supply for stage lighting and full lights took it out in about 20 seconds. When full up was needed it was the sound engineers job to hold the breaker in and to watch the clock for 2 minutes afterwards before releasing.

The company electrician kept trying to say there was not a problem as we only had about 20KW of lighting...

C50's were popular of generators too and a piece of string seemed to be one of the first things to be added to hold it on.
 
The Crabtree C50 range could be held on....
I have to take your word for that but, if so, from considerations of safety I would describe that as a 'design fault' - the electrical equivalent of having an overflow pipe or pressure release valve with a built-in way of 'disabling its intended safety function' by manual action!

Kind Regards, John
 
Sponsored Links
I'd be very supprised if you could hold even an old crabtree C50 closed against a fault, certainly the old loadmasters(and arguably being a worse product, being type 4) that were around at the time were not subceptable to that.according to the original manufacturers data sheets from the 70s. I do know that C50s were hydralic in nature (think john ward took one apart on you tube) so how this affects things I do not know.

Imagine the effect is something like that if a breaker is only just on the point of tripping, then if the toggle is held up, the little bit of mechanical resistance through the mechanism can turn a marginal trip, into a marginal non-trip, outside this marginal window though the extra mechanical resistance is not sufficent to stop the breaker unlatching independant of the mechanism, so the characteristics have changed slightly but still within the allowable tolerance for the device. I've seen this happen on at least one occasion (and heard - you can hear the breaker nearly trip, but not quite get there). Board change in a bakery, three phase dough hook on a 20A Type 2 before, due to someone not ordering it correctly it ended up on a 20A type B which it threw out everytime it tried to start, bit of a mad scramble at silly O clock and we managed to turn up a 20A type C, which would let it start about half the time, or every time if someone held against it. Now type 2 has a magnetic tripping range of somewhere between 4 and 7 times, type B between 3 and 5, type C between 5 and 10. Now I can only assume that the old type type 2 happened to be something like 6 times, but the newer breakers were intended to hit the more sensitive part of the tripping range. It ended up going back on a type D (10-20)
 
Indeed - but, as I said, I can't see that locking it 'on' would be safe practice unless there were some other means of at least 'de-energising' (if not 'isolating') the circuit - and the existence of such an 'other means' would presumably undermine any perceived reason for locking the MCB on, wouldn't it?

Kind Regards, John
Main isolator would still be usable I guess
 
I have to agree with @Adam_151 even the old loadmaster MCB's could not be held on, however the MCB only went to 70 amp but there was a 100 amp device, but it was an isolator not an MCB I had a foreman who had not realised the 100A device was not a MCB it was only an isolator.
 
I have never seen dash pots in MCB's, and I know the dash pots on over loads did dry out, and required topping up, but last dash pot I have worked on must have been around 1985, even rarer than the old ELCB-v.
 
The Crabtree C50 range could be held on, one of the theatres I worked in had a 30A 3ph supply for stage lighting and full lights took it out in about 20 seconds. When full up was needed it was the sound engineers job to hold the breaker in and to watch the clock for 2 minutes afterwards before releasing.

The company electrician kept trying to say there was not a problem as we only had about 20KW of lighting...

C50's were popular of generators too and a piece of string seemed to be one of the first things to be added to hold it on.
Crabtree used to sell a red cover with a sort of leg on it that slipped over the C50 lever, they were quite common on Fire alarm circuits to stop people turning them off.
Not sure regarding whether they still tripped internally
 

DIYnot Local

Staff member

If you need to find a tradesperson to get your job done, please try our local search below, or if you are doing it yourself you can find suppliers local to you.

Select the supplier or trade you require, enter your location to begin your search.


Are you a trade or supplier? You can create your listing free at DIYnot Local

 
Sponsored Links
Back
Top