Yes that is the case, but they are different issues and would receive different codes.
Are you saying that a single up-front 30 mA RCD would only get a C3 (i.e. a 'pass' as far as a 'landlord EICR' {or, I suppose, any other EICR} was concerned)?Yes that is the case, but they are different issues and would receive different codes.
Are you implying that, for some properties, you would give it a C"? If so, what sort of features of the property would cause you to make that decision?Possibly yes, but it depends on the specific property.
You may need to talk to scousespark about that, since it sounds horribly as if you are talking about a 'risk assessment' (which he seems to believe is not appropriate in a domestic setting)It depends. If there's a vulnerable customer on a ventilator and dialysis with a lash up of outdoor ponds and garden lights, then it's very different to a top floor bedsit with two circuits and would most likely be coded differently.
As I keep saying to you, I don't think you should hold your breath, because I'm not sure that any Court will ever be asked to decide about the coding of EICRs!.... So we come to let the courts decide ....
if it was not potentially dangerous in 1960
Indeed, and I've often made similar points (although I'd be happier with your specific examples if they related o a date a bit early than 1960).I don't think that follows. Like Asbestos, cigarettes and leaded petrol?
You may need to talk to scousespark about that, since it sounds horribly as if you are talking about a 'risk assessment' (which he seems to believe is not appropriate in a domestic setting)
But, yes, I personally agree that, in 'extreme' situations, 'risk assessment' is appropriate - but dwellings with ventilators and dialysis machines are hardly things you will come across every day (maybe not every year!)
Kind Regards, John
Indeed, and I had already questioned the conclusion/'belief' that his 'risk assessment' had led him to.I was referring specifically to Eric posting that a Risk Assessment in a domestic setting led him to believe no RCD was required.
... and your original comment was:I pointed out that the regs did not allow for a Risk Assessment in a dwelling.
However, as you now go on to write:A risk assessment is not applicable in a domestic installation.
With which I would certainly agree. If I understand correctly, it therefore seems that you are making a distinction between "a Risk Assessment" and "assessing the risks". Is that the case?We all assess risks every day, whether or not it is formal.
If you need to find a tradesperson to get your job done, please try our local search below, or if you are doing it yourself you can find suppliers local to you.
Select the supplier or trade you require, enter your location to begin your search.
Are you a trade or supplier? You can create your listing free at DIYnot Local