Legionella

Joined
20 Nov 2005
Messages
389
Reaction score
17
Location
Yorkshire
Country
United Kingdom
Below is a copy of a paragraph taken from a Legionella risk assessment given to a landlord I work for:

"If the tank is to remain it will need to be brought up to WRAS standards and inspected/cleaned annually which could be more expensive than fitting a new combi boiler."

It is a domestic property with a traditional galvanised tank and un-lagged copper cylinder.

Obviously tenant safety is important but I was hoping that someone on here could clarify if it is now a legal requirement that a landlord must upgrade an older style hot water system .

 
Sponsored Links
Joined
1 Jul 2007
Messages
56,034
Reaction score
9,554
Location
Hertfordshire & London
Country
United Kingdom
Need more information on the property. Galvanised cisterns are not going to be in a very good condition by now, and can be a monumental ball ache to get rid of, most get left in the corner of the loft when a plastic one is fitted to replace them.

The lagging of the cylinder is irrelevant. It is the temperature it is heated to that is key.
 
Joined
1 Jul 2007
Messages
56,034
Reaction score
9,554
Location
Hertfordshire & London
Country
United Kingdom
Sounds like sales talk,


I can think of one or two on my clients where it would be the case that changing the cistern rather than just disconnecting the lot and fitting a combi would be more expensive - ex council flats with the cisterns entombed in cupboards on stair wells. It is the whole job cost of removing, remaking and redecorating these cupboards that escalates an otherwise simple job.

In fact, we have one where the F&E is Galv and is leaking - that we are changing to preserve the old E-type boiler in the kitchen, but the cold water cistern is on notice - that is not coming out of where it lives.

Ceilings there are concrete, and there are flats above the customers.
 
Joined
20 Nov 2005
Messages
389
Reaction score
17
Location
Yorkshire
Country
United Kingdom
Rules&rulers

I carry out all aspects of property maintenance in Leeds area.

Why do you ask ?
 
R

rules&rulers

I carry out all aspects of property maintenance in Leeds area.

Why do you ask ?

I only asked as legionella awareness has been around for a while now, as you know as you asked a question here about legionella and dead legs a while ago.
You seem to use this site to carry out your trade asking lots of various questions (1 below),you are a qualified person and should know how to access reference material.

Baxi 51/5 BBU
Just replaced pcb on this model boiler (as per MI fault finding chart) still having problems. I read a previous post from here that "it was best...
 
Sponsored Links
Joined
20 Nov 2005
Messages
389
Reaction score
17
Location
Yorkshire
Country
United Kingdom
Rules&rulers

It would be so easy to "bite" and engage in :
"reason why this site exists"

However. I have more productive, more positive things to do with my time.

Thank you
to the people who provided more helpful responses.
 
D

Doggit

A landlord has to make a Leigonaires assemnet before a new tenant moves in, and give it to them prior to the commencement of the tennancy. A combi boiler has a low risk as there is no standing water, whereas a hot water tank, and cold water tank both have standing water that can harbour Legionaires, but as Dan says, as long as it's heated to 60C to kill the bacteria, then the risk is eliminated on the hot side. So the next question on the assesment, would be if the cold water tank then fed the bath.

Obviously the tank should be lagged as part of the energy efficiency requirements, and without that, the temperature in the tank could fall below the required temp to kill the legionalla bacteria (if there are any) but there are no other requirements that I can think off.

There are no legal requirements for the landlord to actually replace anything, only to manage the risk, and inform the tennats if there is one.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Joined
20 Mar 2009
Messages
8,745
Reaction score
1,627
Location
Potters Bar
Country
United Kingdom
It's also important to note that CWSC/T's are also lagged to stop the contained water rising to levels promoting legionella bacteria growth - during hot weather in a loft space that is fabricated as a "cold roof".
 
Joined
4 Oct 2012
Messages
9,116
Reaction score
2,702
Location
East Renfrewshire
Country
United Kingdom
Needs to be noted that legionella can live in old cold water cisterns, especially ones that aren't Bylaw 30 compliant and that aren't piped correctly, so it's as prevalent for the CWSC as well as the HW cylinder.

Edited for some shocking spelling :whistle:
 
Last edited:
Joined
25 Apr 2016
Messages
1,455
Reaction score
278
Country
United Kingdom
Sounds like a plumber did the assessment...

Question - does the cold water tank supply bathroom cold taps and toilet? If they are can they be changed over to be mains fed? If they can then do that.

As for the hot water;
  1. Insulate the cylinder
  2. if necessary, insulate the hot water piping.
  3. Turn the heat up to 60 degrees C (minimum).
  4. Once the cylinder is heated to 60C check that the temp on the most distant hot tap will reach 55C (quickly).
Is the property a 'HMO'? If so then now all hot taps ought to have warning signs e.g. 'Caution – Very Hot Water'.

(The turning up the water temp is a contradiction of a previous ruling where landlords had to turn the Hot Water temp down to 50 degrees C to prevent scolding...)
 
Sponsored Links
Top