At 50cm away and 2.7m tall the zone of influence in low shrink soils won’t reach 2.5m so trench fill is ok if removed.True, although at 50cm away from the tree you still won’t be outside of its influence zone if the soil is cohesive.
It was more of a general comment about people assuming that just removing a tree is a fix-all solution for building near trees, which seems to be a fairly common misconception (I’ve no doubt that Jeds knows his stuff and this commented wasn’t directed at him)
However, there may still be stability issues and a good chance the tree will not survive having half its roots cut off.
True re. the misconception. I’m regularly having to explain to clients that they will still need deep foundations even if a tree is removed. Clay can take ten years or more to fully rehydrate following tree removal.