Stainless Steel v's Galvanised

As mentioned the £2 is a moot point. You have claimed that using galv ties is not appropriate. It is. Your sentiment is unfounded hence bad advice.
 
Sponsored Links
The gist of your whole argument is that galvanised ties are not appropriate, they are "illegal", and that there is or will be a major problem with rusting ties in need of replacement else dire consequences ensue.

All of that is wrong and misleading.

Whether its a £2 or 40% increase in costs depends on your perspective, but the OP thought it relevant to ask the question.

Its actually not worth building a porch in cavity walling anyway, so the OP could save even more money and have less worry about ties, but thats for another thread
 
A SIMPLE QUESTION TO WHICH I WOULD LIKE A SIMPLE YES OR NO



IS IT POSSIBLE FOR GALVANIZED TIES TO RUST OVER A PERIOD OF TIME?
 
Sponsored Links
As mentioned the £2 is a moot point. You have claimed that using galv ties is not appropriate. It is. Your sentiment is unfounded hence bad advice.


You claim the £2 is a moot point, so as it's of little or no consequence what the CUF is the problem, a paltry £2 spent on a superior product!

I think it's not just woody that should stick to digging holes!
 
It's not that simple

Galvanised ties in the Atlantic Ocean (yes) or on the moon (no)

What period of time are we talking about? The life of a porch or the life of the Universe?
 
It is. It is also possible that stainless steel ties could fail. But that doesn’t matter, your advice is still incorrect and thus; bad.
 
It's not that simple

Galvanised ties in the Atlantic Ocean (yes) or on the moon (no)

What period of time are we talking about? The life of a porch or the life of the Universe?



So as we are considerably closer to the Atlantic Ocean than we are the moon! Stainless steel it is then! Thank you woody.
 
WTF are you talking about? Are you drunk man? :eek: :rolleyes:

Cavity trays are required over openings to stop water draining from the cavity, and that has nothing to do with protecting galvanised lintels

Have you actually got any qualifications in surveying?

In fact, did you get any A-levels? or even the odd GCSE?(certainly not in chemistry).

The cavity tray above a galvanised lintel is primarily to protect the galvanizing from attack by the mortar as it gradually turns acidic.

It's bizarre that a supposed surveyor does not know that - it's basic stuff.
 
The cavity tray above a galvanised lintel is primarily to protect the galvanizing from attack by the mortar as it gradually turns acidic.

Tell you what, you reference some recognised standards which state that DPC as a cavity tray is required to "protect lintels" and not to stop moisture penetration.

Go on, I'll wait .....

In the meantime you have not answered my question as to whether a galvanised steel lintel in a solid wall needs a DPC over it to "protect it"

I'll wait for that too ....
 
YOU haven't explained why my galvanized lintel (sans dpc) is slowly rusting.

All manufacturers of these things recommend fitting a dp membrane above, not just to protect the opening, but to protect the zinc coating from the mortar as it carbonates.

There will be a BS somewhere on this, but life's to short to go trawling through material for this.
 
Hi All

Im currently building a porch, well im now ready to starting bringing the walls up once i have ordered everything this aft. Anyway, I was about to purchase the wall ties and stumbled across 2 types. So my question is which ones should i get. Stainless steel or galvanised wall ties? theres only about £2 difference so i was going to go safe with the Stainless but your thoughts are welcome.

Many thanks
Have a read here, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tie_(cavity_wall)
 
I'm in the process of buying a 1930s semi in BS7, on the "Mortgage Valuation Report" page 2, "Matters Affecting Value" I quote "Some properties in this area are known to be affected by failure of the cavity wall ties and a specialist inspection is recommended" unquote.
 

DIYnot Local

Staff member

If you need to find a tradesperson to get your job done, please try our local search below, or if you are doing it yourself you can find suppliers local to you.

Select the supplier or trade you require, enter your location to begin your search.


Are you a trade or supplier? You can create your listing free at DIYnot Local

 
Sponsored Links
Back
Top