Which Building Design Would You Choose PLAN A OR PLAN B

[LetsTalk]

PLAN C

Well that was really helpful - THANKS !!!

Sorry Mr Chattyman, I forgot to say PLAN C has an underground walkway 2.5 metres wide, 3 metres below ground level linking back garden to front.

Chattyman?, letsTalk is female and thanks for a brain wave of an idea, why did i not think of that, i must have had a blonde moment, or maybe you did

 

[wavetrain]

Well actaully I first wrote 'Chatterbox' but then felt Mr Chattyman was funnier, you are not sexist or lacking a sense of humour are you?

 

[RonnyRaygun]

Well actaully I first wrote 'Chatterbox' but then felt Mr Chattyman was funnier, you are not sexist or lacking a sense of humour are you?

I'm just picturing a very camp man with dodgy teeth and glasses

 

[LetsTalk]

Well actaully I first wrote 'Chatterbox' but then felt Mr Chattyman was funnier, you are not sexist or lacking a sense of humour are you?

Are you ?

 

[LetsTalk]

Well actaully I first wrote 'Chatterbox' but then felt Mr Chattyman was funnier, you are not sexist or lacking a sense of humour are you?

I'm just picturing a very camp man with dodgy teeth and glasses

Nope way.

 

[JohnD]

No glasses?

 

[wavetrain]

LOL .... you want people who won't be living there, won't be paying for it and won't be recouping the profit/loss at sale time to decide which extension you should have?

Why don't you just get a design that includes all the features you want?

Just getting public opinions no harm in that surely. At the end of the day when i come to sell prop i am interested in what potential buyers would go for and not just over personalising the property. It is obvious from your comments neither design would work for you, so no prob just don't bother answering my post.

The type of questions, the manic demands for replies and rude nature of this newcomer reminds me of another woman a few months back who used to talk about her questions being like 'how long is a piece of string' in her posts. I wonder if they are the same person?

 

[LetsTalk]

LOL .... you want people who won't be living there, won't be paying for it and won't be recouping the profit/loss at sale time to decide which extension you should have?

Why don't you just get a design that includes all the features you want?

Just getting public opinions no harm in that surely. At the end of the day when i come to sell prop i am interested in what potential buyers would go for and not just over personalising the property. It is obvious from your comments neither design would work for you, so no prob just don't bother answering my post.

The type of questions, the manic demands for replies and rude nature of this newcomer reminds me of another woman a few months back who used to talk about her questions being like 'how long is a piece of string' in her posts. I wonder if they are the same person?

Mr Bully Boy

 

[Nige F]

LOL .... you want people who won't be living there, won't be paying for it and won't be recouping the profit/loss at sale time to decide which extension you should have?

Why don't you just get a design that includes all the features you want?

Just getting public opinions no harm in that surely. At the end of the day when i come to sell prop i am interested in what potential buyers would go for and not just over personalising the property. It is obvious from your comments neither design would work for you, so no prob just don't bother answering my post.

The type of questions, the manic demands for replies and rude nature of this newcomer reminds me of another woman a few months back who used to talk about her questions being like 'how long is a piece of string' in her posts. I wonder if they are the same person?

Mr Bully Boy

Rude nature you wanna get in the plumbing forum more often - that`s RUDE

 

[congokeith]

I had exactly the same situation and built right up to the boundary incorporating a passageway front to back with doors
You may lose a bit on the ground floor but you gain the max above
Check out the party wall act as you can build astride the boundary line and footings can overhang nextdoor. talk to your neighbour
with hindsight I would have built astride not up to I also regret not using a gable end (I moved the hip over) and lost a lot of headroom for stairs etc.
good luck

 

[LetsTalk]

I had exactly the same situation and built right up to the boundary incorporating a passageway front to back with doors
You may lose a bit on the ground floor but you gain the max above
Check out the party wall act as you can build astride the boundary line and footings can overhang nextdoor. talk to your neighbour
with hindsight I would have built astride not up to I also regret not using a gable end (I moved the hip over) and lost a lot of headroom for stairs etc.
good luck

Thanks for the great advice appreciate your honest answer

 

[^woody^]

Check out the party wall act as you can build astride the boundary line and footings can overhang nextdoor.

The PWA does not give you right to build a wall across the boundary - you need the landowners express consent for that

The PWA does give the right to lay foundations astride the boundary if they are necessary, but not reinforced ones. However, I'd argue that they are not necessary as an engineer can calculate an alternative foundation design