'85 @ 12 bar is about 40 kw input. so waaaay over gassed.
check burner rating on data plate .head settings etc. could be wrong burner.
what smoke no is it ? FGA readings ????
If it was watertight before the new roof and leadwork then why should it need a tray now.
I have Fitted liners to and relined with " Isokearn" hundreds of flues.
I have never seen a tray fitted.
I was under the impression that an EICR Was like a gas safety inspection, ie A report on the installation as found at the time of inspection Not a pass or fail,