Bulger murderer denied parole.

[Mottie]

So are you saying that a retrospective full life sentence should be imposed?

Along with many other people like him that have committed horrific crimes?

The problem is with that thinking is that there are people who have been wrongly convicted who would have never been allowed to gain their freedom.

There is no perfect system, but to allow that system a chance to make a periodical judgement and hold it accountable is a far better thing...

After all, you could find yourself facing such an injustice...

Of course you'd deny that could ever happen, but it has been done to many innocent people in the past!

The knee jerk reaction (which I have in the past in part agreed with) is to have convictions where 'life means life'...

But it has to be done at the time, and with the chance to appeal at a later date given evidence that may have not been available at the time...

Bleeding heart ellal has spoken.

 

[Brigadier]

Bleeding heart ellal has spoken.

Attack the argument, not the poster

 

[Odds]

Attack the argument, not the poster

You must be new here...

 

[Brigadier]

You must be new here...

 

[motorbiking]

So are you saying that a retrospective full life sentence should be imposed?

Along with many other people like him that have committed horrific crimes?

The problem is with that thinking is that there are people who have been wrongly convicted who would have never been allowed to gain their freedom.

There is no perfect system, but to allow that system a chance to make a periodical judgement and hold it accountable is a far better thing...

After all, you could find yourself facing such an injustice...

Of course you'd deny that could ever happen, but it has been done to many innocent people in the past!

The knee jerk reaction (which I have in the past in part agreed with) is to have convictions where 'life means life'...

But it has to be done at the time, and with the chance to appeal at a later date given evidence that may have not been available at the time...

This is so confused.

Firstly we are not talking about miscarriages of justice, for which there is an appeals process. We are talking about people who have been given life sentences (or in this case indeterminate sentences, due to being convicted as a child).

A life sentence does mean life. That is not to be confused with how much jail time you do. If you are ever released, you are released under licence. You are subject to recall for the rest of your life.

 

[THFC]

It's amazing he has survived in prison really. Guess he spends a lot of time alone.

He has probably been kept with the other nonces rather than the general population.

 

[Mottie]

Attack the argument, not the poster

Stop attacking me.