ICE told to get the eff out

Highway Man · 2026-01-18T19:14:51+0000

warey4life said:
Shooting her in the face was ridiculous.

She wasn't shot in her face

MNW67 · 2026-01-18T19:16:53+0000

Highway Man said:
Rightly so. I would have been more shocked if no charges were brought to her doorstep.

Well luckily, we have it all on video. How do you think Becca impeded the agent. As I've mentioned before, the worst thing she did was call him 'big boy' and tell him to go on his lunch break.

Lirefighter · 2026-01-18T19:16:54+0000

MNW67 said:
I have wondered the same thing. But it might come up against the First Amendment, from which stems the right to protest. It's tricky.

Protest is one thing, but alerting criminals of law enforcement presence is entirely different. I couldn't believe they were actually allowed to do it.
What about the organisation that provide the whistles etc for the sole purpose of alerting criminals?

warey4life · 2026-01-18T19:19:25+0000

motorbiking said:
Her wife is being investigated for obstruction. I think under the circumstances they should let that slide.

Of course they should.

Highway Man said:
Rightly so. I would have been more shocked if no charges were brought to her doorstep.

I'm sure you are arguing against reality because you adore Trump.

Highway Man · 2026-01-18T19:20:39+0000

warey4life said:
Of course they should.

I'm sure you are arguing against reality because you adore Trump.

No not at all but a bit obvious she would face charges.

MNW67 · 2026-01-18T19:21:08+0000

Lirefighter said:
Protest is one thing, but alerting criminals of law enforcement presence is entirely different. I couldn't believe they were actually allowed to do it.
What about the organisation that provide the whistles etc for the sole purpose of alerting criminals?

It is tricky. I had to Google. Again! Sorry.

AI Overview

Yes, the First Amendment generally protects the right of individuals to blow whistles, shout warnings, or record Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents in public
, as this is considered protected speech and assembly. However, this protection is not absolute and does not allow for physical obstruction of law enforcement,, such as blocking vehicles or preventing arrests.
Here are the legal boundaries regarding this activity based on recent reports:

Protected Activities: Making noise, blowing whistles, yelling to warn others of ICE presence, and filming agents in public spaces are protected by the First Amendment. These actions are considered "peaceful and unobstructive" protests.
Illegal Activities (Obstruction): Protesters cannot physically interfere with, stop an arrest, block roadways, or cause harm to federal officers. Doing so can lead to charges of obstructing or impeding federal officers.
Legal Risks: While generally protected, warning people about raids can still lead to arrest, and in some contexts, officials may attempt to argue such actions constitute "obstruction" or "harboring" if they go beyond simply spreading awareness and actively help someone evade detention.
Context: The use of whistles and other signals has become a common form of protest by "ICE Watch" groups in cities like Chicago, Los Angeles, and Minneapolis to inform communities of raids.

In summary, blowing a whistle to alert people to a raid is generally a legal, protected activity, provided it is done from a safe distance and does not physically interfere with the agents' actions.

warey4life · 2026-01-18T19:22:12+0000

Highway Man said:
She wasn't shot in her face

Shooting her in the head was ridiculous.

Highway Man · 2026-01-18T19:23:22+0000

MNW67 said:
Well luckily, we have it all on video. How do you think Becca impeded the agent. As I've mentioned before, the worst thing she did was call him 'big boy' and tell him to go on his lunch break.

Not going around in circles, you have seen the video, she incited her wife into her actions.

Highway Man · 2026-01-18T19:24:15+0000

warey4life said:
Shooting her in the head was ridiculous.

To you maybe. Not for the ICE agent who she ran over

MNW67 · 2026-01-18T19:25:08+0000

Highway Man said:
Not going around in circles, you have seen the video, she incited her wife into her actions.

I agree with you on that. But I can't see how that amounts to obstruction of the agent. It has to be direct action by her, as far as I know.

The investigation into Becca Good is focused on the first statute listed in Bondi’s memo, a section of the U.S. Code on “assaulting, resisting, or impeding federal officers,” the people said.

warey4life · 2026-01-18T19:25:34+0000

Highway Man said:
Not going around in circles, you have seen the video, she incited her wife into her actions.

Renee good was just waiting in her car while her Mrs was recording things on her phone.

Highway Man · 2026-01-18T19:26:51+0000

warey4life said:
Renee good was just waiting in her car while her Mrs was recording things on her phone.

yes parked in the middle of the road lengthways on, sensible parking.

motorbiking · 2026-01-18T19:38:46+0000

MNW67 said:
It is tricky. I had to Google. Again! Sorry.

AI Overview

Yes, the First Amendment generally protects the right of individuals to blow whistles, shout warnings, or record Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents in public
, as this is considered protected speech and assembly. However, this protection is not absolute and does not allow for physical obstruction of law enforcement,, such as blocking vehicles or preventing arrests.
Here are the legal boundaries regarding this activity based on recent reports:

Protected Activities: Making noise, blowing whistles, yelling to warn others of ICE presence, and filming agents in public spaces are protected by the First Amendment. These actions are considered "peaceful and unobstructive" protests.

Illegal Activities (Obstruction): Protesters cannot physically interfere with, stop an arrest, block roadways, or cause harm to federal officers. Doing so can lead to charges of obstructing or impeding federal officers.

Legal Risks: While generally protected, warning people about raids can still lead to arrest, and in some contexts, officials may attempt to argue such actions constitute "obstruction" or "harboring" if they go beyond simply spreading awareness and actively help someone evade detention.

Context: The use of whistles and other signals has become a common form of protest by "ICE Watch" groups in cities like Chicago, Los Angeles, and Minneapolis to inform communities of raids.

In summary, blowing a whistle to alert people to a raid is generally a legal, protected activity, provided it is done from a safe distance and does not physically interfere with the agents' actions.

Shame she didn’t do that.

MNW67 · 2026-01-18T19:40:53+0000

motorbiking said:
Shame she didn’t do that.

Did you not understand Lirefighter's question.

Highway Man · 2026-01-18T19:46:41+0000

MNW67 said:
Illegal Activities (Obstruction): Protesters cannot physically interfere with, stop an arrest, block roadways, or cause harm to federal officers. Doing so can lead to charges of obstructing or impeding federal officers.

Clearly see where she went wrong.

ICE told to get the eff out

Similar threads