Judaism is now a Nationality

[EFLImpudence]

Cultural.

So - not race nor religion, then.

Why not? You could argue that people who celebrate Christmas, enjoy watching their kids do the nativity play and happily sing Christmas carols, but do not believe in God, are Atheist Christians.

I intentionally did not say Christian as one could follow the teachings of Christ simply because they are a good idea so would that just be cultural as well?

Anyway, not believing in god would seem to preclude one from being a member or follower of that religion.

 

[JP_]

But, that is the point, it is more than just a religion, it is cultural.

They could be Muslim.

or Jedi, or any other religion for that matter - many are!

 

[JP_]

So - not race nor religion, then.

Not sure how we got there. I said "it obviously has more meaning to jews than just the religious aspect.", you asked "how?" and I said "cultural"
But obviously includes religion for many too!

Why are we even talking about this though?

 

[ellal]

Unless you really really hate jews, does any of this really matter?

Ask the tories if it matters!

 

[EFLImpudence]

Not sure how we got there. I said "it obviously has more meaning to jews than just the religious aspect.", you asked "how?" and I said "cultural"
But obviously includes religion for many too!

Yes, but culture is not a race - the point of the thread.

Why are we even talking about this though?

Because you keep replying.