Removing Asbestos soffits

[GinSoakedBoy]

I am looking at doing some work to rectify the past owners poor gutting / fascia install and have been contemplating removing the asbestos cement soffits (Structurally sound but look shabby). I know the usual advice is to not disturb, but I have been mulling over a feasible and safe way to remove the soffits without damaging them or breaking them up.

My thoughts on how this could be done -

Idea one - would be to extract the nails from below (but getting behind the nail heads will likely cause damage).
Idea two - would be to remove the lower row of tiles above and then try and force the panel / rafter apart to loosen the nails (maybe block of wood and mallet / or a wrecking bar, then separate that way?

I am interested in whether anyone has a better solution for doing this without damaging the asbestos?


Extra info -

The house is single story so access (other than the gable end isn't an issue).
I have removed asbestos before so aware of the safety precautions.
I have had it tested and it is asbestos - Chrysotile.
I have spoken to a few places about removal and the quotes were comical.


Thanks in advance for the advice.

Regards

James

 

[Munroast]

p3 mask, outdoors - cement board
I would probably risk it

But saying that I had aunts and uncles die of asbestosis (worked in a local asbestos factory (kids used to sledge on the snow heap), and it is a terrible way to die

i too have worked with asbestos many years ago, and if ever I get a bit of a cough I worry its the start.

so yes save some money then spnd years worrying about something that may never happen

 

[Old Salt]

I have worked with asbestos and one of my friends died just over 12 months ago from mesothelioma Whatever method you choose is liable to cause some damage. I would dampen it down before removing and tackle the nail heads.

Alternatively and more safely I would paint it.