This Land is Our Land

If the Judeans were not exiled from their country, and if there was never a large-scale emigration of its agrarian population, what was the historical fate of most of the inhabitants?

There was no forced expulsion after the destruction of the second temple - it was only the conquest of Arab invaders in the 7th century that uprooted masses of Judeans from their native land and made it the homeland of strangers. Most scholars agree that between the fall of the Judean kingdom in 70ce and the Moslem conquest 600 years later, there seemed to be a Judean majority between the Jordan river and the Mediterranean.

In 324ce the province of Palestine became a Christian Protectorate, and a large number of Palestinians became Christian - Jerusalem gradually became a largely Christian city. It seems the 'disappearance' of Jews from the country coincided with the conversion of many of them to Christianity.

This is why Netanyahu's government sought control over archaeological sites in Gaza to substantiate their claims to Palestinian land In June. Alternatives for controversial legislation aimed at establishing an Israeli authority over antiquities and ancient sites in the occupied West Bank and Gaza are now being considered after critics and international organizations warned the bill would weaponize heritage management to expand control and seize land.

Netanyahu has frequently used archaeological tours and heritage narratives—such as joint site visits in Jerusalem with US and political figures—to emphasize historical and biblical ties, a strategy critics describe as leveraging archaeology for territorial and political goals.

The land they seek to annexe was never theirs to begin with.
 

Yeh, they would say that. DARVO.

The UN.


"In 2025, patterns of sexual violence against Palestinians detained in Israel and the Occupied Palestinian Territory continued to be documented. The cases verified by the United Nations should be seen as indicative of incidents and patterns over multiple reporting periods rather than comprehensive, given the continued denial of access by the Government of Israel to detention settings, as well as to Gaza. Challenges to reporting sexual violence persisted, due to, inter alia, explicit threats made by Israeli armed and security forces coercing detainees not to report abuse. According to the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR), while the Comprehensive Plan resulted in the release of 1,968 Palestinians detained by the Israeli authorities, over 9,000 remained in detention, including over 4,000 detained without charges or trial or administratively detained, raising concerns of arbitrary detention. In 2025, the United Nations verified multiple incidents of conflict-related sexual violence, including as a form of torture, inflicted against 14 men, 7 women, 9 boys and 1 girl from the Gaza Strip and the West Bank. Thirteen of these cases occurred in 2025, and 18 in 2023 and 2024. Violations consisted of rape, including with objects, gang rape, attempted rape, physical violence to the genitals, instances of targeted shooting of the genitals, touching of breasts and genitals, strip and cavity searches conducted without apparent security justification, forced nudity and threats of rape. Rape and gang rape, in some cases repeated, were perpetrated against nine victims, the majority from Gaza. Perpetrators included Israeli armed and security forces, namely the Israel Defense Forces, Israel Prison Service, including the Keter special forces, and the Police Counter-Terrorism Unit (Yamam). These violations occurred primarily during detention and interrogation and across several sites, including military camps (Sde Teiman, Etzion detention centre, Majnunah camp and an unidentified base); Israel Prison Service facilities (Megiddo, Ofer, Ramla, Hasharon, Shatta, Nafha and Damon); and at an Israeli police station (Gush Etzion police station). In addition, violations were perpetrated at checkpoints and during Israeli military operations in the Occupied Palestinian Territory. Survivors included journalists and human rights defenders. Most cases involved multiple forms of sexual violence used simultaneously and, in some cases, the violations were filmed or photographed, including one case of rape. Sexual violence against female detainees included mostly threats of rape, forced nudity, unwanted touching, and humiliating or degrading strip searches without justification, while men and boys were targeted with rape, attempted rape and violence to the genitals, resulting in five male victims suffering severe rectal bleeding or swelling for multiple days or weeks and, in some cases, without receiving medical treatment. The long-term effects of sexual violence on detainees released back to Gaza were further compounded by dire living conditions (see A/HRC/60/CRP.3). Moreover, due to the humanitarian disaster and repeated mass displacements caused by the conflict (see A/HRC/58/28), women and girls in Gaza continue to be exposed to heightened risks of sexual violence."
 
I noticed a comment by the Board of Deputies of British Jews, and I thought of comparisons:
"No political party has the right to tell Jews that a central part of our identity, rooted in thousands of years of history, faith and peoplehood, is racist."

How about I change a couple of words and compare the result:

"No political party has the right to tell South Africans that a central part of our identity, rooted in hundreds of years of history, faith and peoplehood, was racist."
Or
"No political party has the right to tell Americans that a central part of our identity, rooted in hundreds of years of history, faith and peoplehood, was racist."
Or
"No political party has the right to tell Australians that a central part of our identity, rooted in hundreds of years of history, faith and peoplehood, was racist."
Or
"No political party has the right to tell Belgians/Dutch/Germans, etc that a central part of our identity, rooted in hundreds of years of history, faith and peoplehood, was racist."

I'm sure there are many more examples.

It strikes me that the Board of Deputies of British Jews is hypocritical. It blatantly denies the racist policies and practices of Israel.

And as for the claim that Israel is a true democracy:


The Jews are not a race.
 
The Jews, nor any other group, are a different "race". All humans are the same race.

Apart from the Chinese. Or Africans....but Judaism is a religion. Not a race. To argue they are is to deny the right of modern Israel to exist.

It's just a label given to ethnocentric or ethnocratic based hatred, prejudice or discrimination.
But that doesn't excuse the racist attitudes of extremist groups.
 
There was no forced expulsion after the destruction of the second temple - it was only the conquest of Arab invaders in the 7th century that uprooted masses of Judeans from their native land and made it the homeland of strangers. Most scholars agree that between the fall of the Judean kingdom in 70ce and the Moslem conquest 600 years later, there seemed to be a Judean majority between the Jordan river and the Mediterranean.

In 324ce the province of Palestine became a Christian Protectorate, and a large number of Palestinians became Christian - Jerusalem gradually became a largely Christian city. It seems the 'disappearance' of Jews from the country coincided with the conversion of many of them to Christianity.

This is why Netanyahu's government sought control over archaeological sites in Gaza to substantiate their claims to Palestinian land In June. Alternatives for controversial legislation aimed at establishing an Israeli authority over antiquities and ancient sites in the occupied West Bank and Gaza are now being considered after critics and international organizations warned the bill would weaponize heritage management to expand control and seize land.

Netanyahu has frequently used archaeological tours and heritage narratives—such as joint site visits in Jerusalem with US and political figures—to emphasize historical and biblical ties, a strategy critics describe as leveraging archaeology for territorial and political goals.

The land they seek to annexe was never theirs to begin with...

...the last Jewish uprising in Galilee in 614ce by Benjamin of Tiberias.
Zionist historians were not mistaken in saying the Jewish presence was drastically reduced following the Moslem conquest, but wrong to say there was a mass exile, either. Islam didn't forcibly remove the indigenous population at all, whether they believed in Yahweh or Christ.

Muhammad's commandment to treat jews and Christians as 'people of the book' gave them legal protection - in a letter to the Army commanders in Southern Arabia instructed them "every person, whether Jew or Christian, who becomes a Moslem is one of the Believers, with the same rights and duties. Anyone who clings to his religion is not to be converted and must pay the poll tax incumbent upon every adult, male or female, free or bond."

Rather than pay the tax, many people chose to convert.

Jewish and Moslem testimonies show that they helped the victorious Arab forces.
 
Back
Top