I see Fillyboy doesnt say which Israeli propaganda source he got this from
how soon will Trump back down over tariffs
- Thread starter Notch7
- Start date
- Status
Filly provides zero evidence to support his Israeli propaganda
- Joined
- 22 Jan 2007
- Messages
- 22,984
- Reaction score
- 3,069
- Country
You said so.
and what a surprise: the source of this claim comes from Honest Reporting (sic)
"Honest Reporting" is a pro Israel pressure group
the words Filly quoted "Quietly change the statistics blah blah blah.................." have been published verbatim in loads of right wing biased publications like the Telegraph, Spectator etc etc
Filly just posts Israel propaganda
Says an Israeli propaganda source.
A peer reviewed source says the deaths in Gaza are much higher
Research published in the Lancet medical journal estimates that the death toll in Gaza during the first nine months of the Israel-Hamas war was about 40% higher than numbers recorded by the Palestinian territory’s health ministry.
The peer-reviewed statistical analysis was conducted by academics at the London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, Yale University and other institutions,
Gaza death toll 40% higher than official number, Lancet study finds
Analysis estimates death toll by end of June was 64,260, with 59% being women, children and people over 65
www.theguardian.com
Hamas admits to lying about Palestinians allegedly killed by Israel | The Jerusalem Post
A similar report by the Henry Jackson Society in December also concluded that Hamas had inflated the number of casualties in the war.
www.jpost.com
Approximately 72% of fatalities are aged 13-55 and are men - the demographic category aligns with Hamas combatants.
Hamas quietly removed the names of thousands of Palestinians it had previously alleged were killed during the Israel-Hamas war, Salo Aizenberg, from the US-based non-profit organisation Honest Reporting told The Telegraph on Tuesday after analyzing Hamas’s March 2025 casualty update.Hamas has previously claimed that 70% of casualties have been women and children, a claim no longer reflected in their recently updated lists, according to the research. Approximately 72% of fatalities between the ages of 13-55 are men - the demographic category aligns with Hamas combatants.
“Hamas’s new March 2025 fatality list quietly drops 3,400 fully ‘identified’ deaths listed in its August and October 2024 reports – including 1,080 children. These ‘deaths’ never happened. The numbers were falsified – again,” Aizenberg asserted.
HonestReporting | Exposing anti-Israel media bias
HonestReporting monitors the news for bias, inaccuracy and other breaches of journalistic standards that create false, if not malicious, narratives about Israel, the broader Middle East and Jews worldwide. HonestReporting is not aligned with any government or political party or movement.
honestreporting.com
- Joined
- 25 Jul 2022
- Messages
- 17,916
- Reaction score
- 1,502
- Country
Honest reporting , hmmmm ?
- Overall, we rate HonestReporting Right-Center Biased based on support for right-leaning nationalist political parties. We also rate them as Mostly Factual rather than High due to the promotion of nationalist propaganda.
Well that's odd.
If the information was coming from the Palestinian government, you'd expect to see quotes of its words, and a link to the source.
Did you look? Where did you find Palestine's statistics, and what did they say? Show us the source of your claims,
Here’s one on today's news for you to get your teeth into Jonnyboy. Away you go. It’s current and topical so even Notch can join in.
Sudan conflict: BBC smuggles phones into el-Fasher to uncover hunger and fear
Rare accounts of life in el-Fasher - the last major city in Darfur controlled by the Sudanese army.
www.bbc.co.uk
Hamas suspected of manipulating Gaza death toll, research shows
Some 3,400 names were removed from the most recent death reports from the Strip, raising concerns of inflated figures by Hamas.
www.euronews.com
Some 3,400 names were removed from the most recent death reports from the Strip, raising concerns of inflated figures by Hamas.
The Hamas-run health ministry in Gaza has removed thousands of names from its death toll in its March casualty update without any notice, a new research by two separate reports claims.Some 3,400 previously identified deaths from its August and October 2024 reports can no longer be found in the PDFs released by the ministry, which doesn’t differentiate between combatants and civilians.
At least 1,000 children are among those no longer on the list, according to two research reports, which corroborated each other's findings.
The data, showing ID numbers that have been removed from the ministry's most recent report, was made public on Monday by Salo Eisenberg, a researcher with the US-based NGO Honest Reporting.
"The lists were quite unreliable. We found rafts and rafts of mistakes," Andrew Fox, associate fellow at the UK-based think tank Henry Jackson Society, told Euronews.
The discrepancy has made researchers concerned about the possibility of numbers being intentionally inflated by Hamas, especially since the health ministry’s figures are widely reported in international media and seen as relevant by the likes of the UN, and triggering widespread social response and even political developments.
The concern is particularly exacerbated by the fact that the lists can be filled by anyone with a link to the document made available on Google Docs.
In turn, this means that Hamas could have gone through the list and deliberately added further names as casualties, affecting the total, but also the demographics of the victims.
"There were three reporting methodologies," said Fox, who published his analysis in December 2024. "There's actually having a physical body in a hospital. There's media sources, so the government media office essentially trawls social media to try and find reports of people who died and they add them to the list."
"And then the third methodology is an online Google form that anyone can just fill in. You could fill it in right now. And that gets added to the list."
The big issue that stems from these findings is the discrepancy between the age and gender of those killed, which can make a difference between pointing to indiscriminate killings and typical combatant casualties in urban warfare, researchers believe, which is a key talking point among the anti-Israeli critics.
At the same time, Gaza is also one of the most densely populated places on Earth where almost 50% of the population is under 18 — compared to 18% in the European Union — meaning a high number of civilian casualties remains plausible, especially among the youth.
This opens the door to the possibility that the militant group is tweaking the numbers to turn the narrative to one of civilian plight and tragedy targeting women and children, while obfuscating its losses — and its role in the conflict.
"If you were seeing indiscriminate killing, you would expect roughly 26% adult male deaths," Fox said. "In the 13 to 55 age group, which is Hamas' fighter range because we know they use child soldiers, it's 72% male in that age group."
"So all these things clearly point towards combatants being targeted rather than just indiscriminate killing."
The Hamas-run health ministry figures were considered accurate in previous conflicts in Gaza as independent international organisations corroborated them.
However, this is no longer the case ever since the start of the Israel-Hamas war sparked by the militant group’s 7 October attacks, killing some 1,200 civilians in Israel and taking hundreds hostage, as it became impossible to verify any claims about the situation on the ground due to a media blackout.
The health ministry has recently claimed that the number of deaths in the Strip has now surpassed 50,000. The Israeli military says it has killed some 20,000 Hamas combatants, while also reporting around 3,000 dead and wounded among its soldiers.
At the same time, it is unclear whether the ministry's computer system outage in November had any impact on the numbers it reported, which Fox says could also explain some of the errors. Other issues with the reports, however, point to questionable practices, he explained.
"I'd be very surprised if natural deaths weren't included on that list, because there's been no separate reporting of natural deaths whatsoever," he said.
"But by the same token, it is also very difficult. So on top of the stats padding, there will also be genuine mistakes on there."
"It's still a tragedy, no matter how many civilians have died," Fox pointed out. "But I think it's been remiss of the world's media to try and take these figures as gospel when plainly there are combatants dying."
“Honest reporting” is a pro Israel propaganda outlet.Hamas admits to lying about Palestinians allegedly killed by Israel | The Jerusalem Post
A similar report by the Henry Jackson Society in December also concluded that Hamas had inflated the number of casualties in the war.
Approximately 72% of fatalities are aged 13-55 and are men - the demographic category aligns with Hamas combatants.
Hamas quietly removed the names of thousands of Palestinians it had previously alleged were killed during the Israel-Hamas war, Salo Aizenberg, from the US-based non-profit organisation Honest Reporting told The Telegraph on Tuesday after analyzing Hamas’s March 2025 casualty update.
Hamas has previously claimed that 70% of casualties have been women and children, a claim no longer reflected in their recently updated lists, according to the research. Approximately 72% of fatalities between the ages of 13-55 are men - the demographic category aligns with Hamas combatants.
“Hamas’s new March 2025 fatality list quietly drops 3,400 fully ‘identified’ deaths listed in its August and October 2024 reports – including 1,080 children. These ‘deaths’ never happened. The numbers were falsified – again,” Aizenberg asserted.
HonestReporting analyzes stories, articles, opinion pieces and images that appear in the media’s coverage of Israel, exposing and responding to inaccuracies or bias. Browse our homepage to see our latest critiques and features, both in written and video form.HonestReporting | Exposing anti-Israel media bias
HonestReporting monitors the news for bias, inaccuracy and other breaches of journalistic standards that create false, if not malicious, narratives about Israel, the broader Middle East and Jews worldwide. HonestReporting is not aligned with any government or political party or movement.
The guy quoted in the article, Salo Aizenberg, is from Honest Reporting. He isn't an unbiased source and Honest Reporting isn't just a "US-based non-profit organisation" as the article states.
It's a US-based pro-Israel organization. Aizneberg is on the Board of Directors of Honest Reporting and according to his LinkedIn seems to be the owner of an investment advisory firm in New York and not any kind of researcher or journalist
Editorially, they hold pro-Israel nationalist positions in favor of Benjamin Netanyahu and the current nationalist parties. Some might call them a propaganda source
Flawed critique: how Andrew Fox’s report on Gaza death toll for the Henry Jackson Society lacks evidence for key claims
Flawed critique: how Andrew Fox's report on Gaza death toll for the Henry Jackson Society lacks evidence for key claims - AOAV
A review of Andrew Fox’s Henry Jackson Society report on Gaza death toll figures finds limited evidence for claims of MoH data manipulation, highlighting errors as random rather than systematic, and somewhat more evidence for media complicity.
aoav.org.uk
- Status