Engine-oil analysis

Joined
24 Aug 2009
Messages
2,714
Reaction score
293
Country
France
Hi

I would be interested if anybody has sent off a sample of their engine-oil for analysis and what they thought of the process/results.

My Vectra 1.8 petrol has done 120 000 miles, seemingly still in very good engine condition, and I was thinking about sending a sample, just from curiosity.
 
Hi

I would be interested if anybody has sent off a sample of their engine-oil for analysis and what they thought of the process/results.

My Vectra 1.8 petrol has done 120 000 miles, seemingly still in very good engine condition, and I was thinking about sending a sample, just from curiosity.

No, I haven't. It generally costs as least as much as an oil change. It's routinely done in ships though. Interestingly, Delco did develop an integrated oil level and quality sensor, some years ago, but that went very quiet... Almost like neither the oil companies nor the manufacturers, nor the dealers, nor the independent garage trade, thought it was a good idea... ;)
 
Wheeler Dealers or another car rebuild programme used it I believe. It will tell you if there are signs of bearing or crankshaft wear etc. But with your mileage that is probably a given anyway. Apparently it can be very informative.

The RN monitors gas turbine wear by analysing debris picked up on magnetic chip detectors which are located in the return oilways. These would identify which parts of the engine may be susceptible to accelerated wear. Engines were changed based on an hours run schedule though rather than normal wear provided the chip detectors were not indicating potential issues.
 
Seen it on car sos. I presume it needs some interpretation - might say it's full of crankshaft metal, but you might have one of those bulletproof engines from the cavalier that will still run another 100k miles with no maintenance - makes you wonder where it all went wrong.
 
Seen it on car sos. I presume it needs some interpretation - might say it's full of crankshaft metal, but you might have one of those bulletproof engines from the cavalier that will still run another 100k miles with no maintenance - makes you wonder where it all went wrong.
Bean counters in charge rather than Engineers
 
My question would be for what purpose, versus cost.
Yes, you - and others - are right there. As I said, I was mainly considering it for the sake of curiosity, although would obviously also have been interested for any analysis/commentary about undue crank/bearing/cylinder wear for example. I was thinking that I would pay up to £40 for this, but a quick search shows that I was aiming low as £65-£75 seems the going rate.

I also considered what use I would make of this, and my conclusion was, essentially, none or maybe little. Whatever the result was I would continue driving until it reached the end of its life, but if the result had been very good, then it might have prompted me to perhaps pay for an undersealing treatment. In spite of being 17 years old, the car is , apparently , in excellent condition, with no signs of rust and none noted from inspections, so it might be worth making an investment in preserving the body if the engine is in good condition.* Although living in the Alps means four+ months of snow, the roads are usually clear , no salt is used and humidity is low .

2008 1.8 Z18 XER petrol, manual box.

My driving style is restrained, seldom hit 3 500 rpm/75 mph, minimum drive usually 12 miles, but bulk of miles added on holiday driving when it's 100 - 200 miles per day (summer/autumn ) and practically no stop-start driving at all. The only oddity here is that I live at 1 400m altitude and can only go up or down:: down to the valley town means a drop of 1 000 m, so every return home means that the engine always reaches 90C. Only engine repair during my eight year ownership was, in fact, a thermostat two years ago. Annual oil-change with recommended oil and quality oil-filter ( Mann ). Taking all that into account, is this engine known for longevity, meaning should I consider the undersealing more than I have been ?

Freddy: as far as interpretation of report goes, I think you would need to investigate individual providers to see what they offer and I only noted the first pricing page.

* It's just occured to me that a possible gearbox oil-change would also be influenced by this. Vauxhall say oil is for life, but numerous forum members say 100 000 miles. My gear-change is extremely smooth and oil-change likely £ 150+. I can afford it, but I really dislike wasting either money or effort/materials.
 
Last edited:
I think the only real need for any analysis would be to contend a warranty issue that had been rejected.

Otherwise, the oil is out, if it is being tested, so new oil is good. And if the engine is worn, no surprise.
 
Seen it on car sos. I presume it needs some interpretation - might say it's full of crankshaft metal, but you might have one of those bulletproof engines from the cavalier that will still run another 100k miles with no maintenance - makes you wonder where it all went wrong.
Yes, where did all went wrong?
We used to have cars easily running 200k miles.
My friend had a Mercedes 300 (gold colour) which run 1 million kilometres.
1 million!
Yes, it was in a temperate climate and he was obsessed with maintenance, but what engine would run 1 million kilometres now?
And what car?
All the rest would disintegrate before the engine gave up.
 
Back
Top