Ideal Logic+ 30 Fix or replace?

Joined
25 Aug 2016
Messages
1,415
Reaction score
371
Country
United Kingdom
Hi all,

Our logic+ 30 combi has been losing pressure slowly for awhile, a local gsr plumber looked at it today and said the main heat exchanger looks like it has a pinhole as there is a constant drip into the condensate trap about every 3 seconds with the boiler fully isolated and switched off.

He also says the flue manifold looks like it has a leak due to build up on the outside of it.

He said he doesn't really deal with ideal boilers so wouldn't be interested in repairing it, but he didn't charge me for looking as he lives round the corner so that's fair enough.

Looking online a new main heat exchanger is about £400 plus whatever a gsr plumber will charge to fit or a reconditioned unit is £145. Unfortunately it's 18 years old so Ideal won't do a fixed price repair.

The boiler works fine apart from needing topping up once or twice a week.

I'd expect a new combi boiler to be at least £2000 so would you be looking to fit a new boiler or get it repaired?

Thanks,
Chris.
 
Tough one. Did you ask your engineer to quote for a new one? Maybe obtain some quotes before settling a decision?
 
Common fault on these. They also get pinholes in the flue manifold, and pressure sensor issues in my experience.

If you're going to replace it, look at the Vokera Pinnacle. 12 year warranty, stainless steel heat exchanger, much better modulation.
 
Hi all,

Our logic+ 30 combi has been losing pressure slowly for awhile, a local gsr plumber looked at it today and said the main heat exchanger looks like it has a pinhole as there is a constant drip into the condensate trap about every 3 seconds with the boiler fully isolated and switched off.

He also says the flue manifold looks like it has a leak due to build up on the outside of it.

He said he doesn't really deal with ideal boilers so wouldn't be interested in repairing it, but he didn't charge me for looking as he lives round the corner so that's fair enough.

Looking online a new main heat exchanger is about £400 plus whatever a gsr plumber will charge to fit or a reconditioned unit is £145. Unfortunately it's 18 years old so Ideal won't do a fixed price repair.

The boiler works fine apart from needing topping up once or twice a week.

I'd expect a new combi boiler to be at least £2000 so would you be looking to fit a new boiler or get it repaired?

Thanks geometry dash full
Chris.
That's certainly a difficult decision! An 18-year-old boiler has already had a pretty good lifespan, but spending £400 on a replacement heat exchanger is still a significant expense. I'd probably get another professional opinion before deciding whether a repair is worthwhile.
 

If you need to find a tradesperson to get your job done, please try our local search below, or if you are doing it yourself you can find suppliers local to you.

Select the supplier or trade you require, enter your location to begin your search.


Are you a trade or supplier? You can create your listing free at DIYnot Local

 
Back
Top