SAD NEWS

[skitzee2k]

OK, do you think there would be the same kind of media frenzy/interest if it were two 10 year old boys

Genuinely don't know

Me neither, is an odd one...probably something to do with our evolutionary psychology to look after females.
[Disclaimer, was genuinely interested in opinions, not trying to say, infer or bait anyone in anyway]...
..think that is me done for the night

 

[skitzee2k]

... ...

OK, i'll try it another way, do you think someone can on the spur of the moment kill someone and still be mentally well, in control of their senses at the time of the killing?
I personally edge towards no, what about you?

 

[lifesagasman]

it happens all the time. it's called war.

 

[Homesafe]

Why are you wasting your time with this loser , he only says what he thinks everyone else should think, like a 'muffler'

 

[skitzee2k]

it happens all the time. it's called war.

Odd way of saying Yes or no.

I'll ask you a more specific senario.
Can a guy who murders a stranger in the street when there is not threat to him by this stranger be "mentally well"?

 

[lifesagasman]

who are you hoping to wind up now, nuke?

 

[skitzee2k]

it happens all the time. it's called war.

Odd way of saying Yes or no.

I'll ask you a more specific senario.
Can a guy who murders a stranger in the street when there is not threat to him by this stranger be "mentally well"?

Please can you answer with a yes or a no so we can clear of what you are saying..for exampel you could be saying all soldiers are mentally ill.

I am honestly just trying to find out your opinion.

 

[lifesagasman]

why the hypothetical scenario? you made 2 statements which, in essence, contradicted each other.

 

[skitzee2k]

Why is it that on this forum no-one wants to tell anyone what their opinion is?

"Can a guy who murders a stranger in the street when there is not threat to him by this stranger be "mentally well"? There is no contradiction here, so feel free to answer.

 

[Homesafe]

This sicko hasn't got an opinion, he follows his conjecture and is deluded to the brink of fantasy, how can he tell you the answer to that simple question?? I don't know

 

[skitzee2k]

This sicko hasn't got an opinion, he follows his conjecture and is deluded to the brink of fantasy, how can he tell you the answer to that simple question?? I don't know

I'm a bit disappointed. The whole 'People who are mentally unwell cannot be tried for murder but can anyone who murders someone be metally well?' bit isn't even my original thought I don't think. I'm quite sure it has been around for a long time. It would seem point scoring is more important to some people than honest conversation.

 

[lifesagasman]

i have freely given my opinion on 2 related threads. read them.

as far as i am concerned you are simply argumentative and frequently contradictory.

the last debacle took the biscuit when you tried to convince the whole forum what a shower of morons go into the army. then you went and 'joined' yourself, but could only manage 3 days!

have a viewpoint, have an opinion, but please don't try to preach to me. you're not good enough at it.

 

[lifesagasman]

This sicko hasn't got an opinion, he follows his conjecture and is deluded to the brink of fantasy, how can he tell you the answer to that simple question?? I don't know

you don't actually know much about anything, nuke.

 

[skitzee2k]

i have freely given my opinion on 2 related threads. read them.

as far as i am concerned you are simply argumentative and frequently contradictory.

the last debacle took the biscuit when you tried to convince the whole forum what a shower of morons go into the army. then you went and 'joined' yourself, but could only manage 3 days!

have a viewpoint, have an opinion, but please don't try to preach to me. you're not good enough at it.

....why can't you just give a yes or no answer man?? It would have taken a fraction of the time, what are you so scared of? Jeez!

I did say, and i stand by that most people in the army are there because they haven't or didn't have much hope in civvy street. I didn't have this opinion when I applied to join them(when I was 16). Everyone got a 3 day taster (i didn't "manage" 3 days, that is how long it was), after seeing it first hand I decided I was too good for it... ANYWAY, that is another thread.

How am I preaching to you by ASKING A QUESTION?

 

[Homesafe]

How am I preaching to you by ASKING A QUESTION?

All you'll get in reply is, blah blah,nuke
Absolute loser, I feel sorry for people who know this cretin