What Boiler Type - Systems or Combi

maybe to those like youself that struggle ;)
What do you know about my struggling? A friend of mine is a gas man, he gets a lot of his guys' work from combi faults, and he wouldn't have one in his own house. I'd guess you're in favour of combis because they're more likely to make you £££.
But you're clearly bent on having an argument, and suffer from lastworditis. Feel free, I'm out of here.
 
What do you know about my struggling? A friend of mine is a gas man, he gets a lot of his guys' work from combi faults, and he wouldn't have one in his own house. I'd guess you're in favour of combis because they're more likely to make you £££.
But you're clearly bent on having an argument, and suffer from lastworditis. Feel free, I'm out of here.
By your previous posts you jump in on things you dont really know about ,the basic motorised valve motor fault being an example . O h you have a friend who is a gasman i have dozens of friends who are gasmen .And only 47 years experience myself and been working on combis for over 40 years they do not make me anymore money than a standard boiler and if you actually read the thread i recommended the guy to keep a normal boiler . I can see you never thought that through
 
  • Thanks
Reactions: DP
......until it goes wrong. Then it's likely to be harder to diagnose and fix. Better to replace with another heat-only boiler.
The advice is to keep the cylinder and heat only/system boiler in this instance.

Proper installers will give the best advice, whether combi or not. No point in sticking to one or the other when not suitable.
 
Last house, had an instant heat gas boiler for DHW and a second boiler for CH, the reason was to turn the large airing cupboard into a child's bedroom, so good reason to get rid of the cylinder, but the pipe work was designed for a cylinder so way over sized for mains pressure hot water, so we could nearly fill a washing up bowl of water in kitchen before we got any hot, and to fill the bath took a good 20 minutes, and we had no immersion heater as a back-up. I think the Main 7 DHW boiler was around the 20 kW mark, and although it would throttle back a bit, we had a problem finding a shower head big enough so the boiler would not cut out.

But we two boilers, the CH boiler was sized for the CH, and not over sized to also do DHW, most homes need around a 12 kW CH boiler, if we just think about it a little, near every room could be heated with a 2 kW panel heater, so 6 rooms = 12 kW, simple maths without going into calculations on to heat loss and recovery times.

Even a shower, an 8 kW shower is not by any means a power shower, but it does the job, and as long as the shower rose is sized for the showers output, it works OK.

The problem is the bath, around 40 gallons in a bath, that is about 9 kWh, so 12 kW boiler would take 45 minutes to heat 50°C. So we ended up with 6" of water in bottom of bath, we soon fitted a shower instead, I am talking about late 70s early 80s, so showers were not the norm back then.

So we saw boilers of 36 kW being fitted, way oversize for CH, but could fill a bath in a reasonable time. However, then we moved to the condensing boiler, designed to extract the latent heat out of the flue gases, and to do that we also moved from on/off (called mark/space) to analogue control, so the boiler modulated (fancy word for turning down output) so the big change was now the minium output also becomes important, and in general the higher the maximum output, the higher the minium output.

So if in the heart of winter you need 12 kW, in Autumn and Spring maybe looking at just 3.5 kW, even then it may still need to cycle a bit, so the less it turns on/off and the more it can modulate the more latent heat is gained so the more efficient the boiler runs.

This is why the heat pump seems to work better, in spite of the increased price of fuel, as they don't in general heat DHW, as DHW has to be over 60°C to be safe, and the heat pump works more efficiently the cooler the water is, so we don't have combi heat pumps, also we don't have combi oil boilers, the latter has a water store inside the boiler casing, neither instant heat the water. So in both cases we see a lot smaller boilers.

So the combi boiler saves space. Full stop. As far as heating DHW goes, far better to have a water store, specially when it also allows you to use off-peak and solar to heat DHW as well.
 
the combi boiler saves space. Full stop. As far as heating DHW goes, far better to have a water store, specially when it also allows you to use off-peak and solar to heat DHW as well.
It depends on the requirements, the system should be designed with a lot of factors in mind then advice given.
 
It depends on the requirements, the system should be designed with a lot of factors in mind then advice given.
Yes, the life style of the occupants has to be considered, the Myson fan assisted I had in the last house was so fast reheating, no need for geo-fencing, this house is so slow in comparison.

But I look at my late parents house, where the steel header tank developed a leak, it was 50 years old, and my parents took the offer of a grant to fit new central heating system.

How anyone felt it needed a 35 kW boiler for a three bedroom house, I really don't know. It seemed as if it was a case we have this in stock, so we will use it.

The thermostat 84067_P.jpgwas expensive, but not suited to the boiler, designed clearly for an on/off boiler not a modulating type, and together with leaving the power shower connected, one has to ask, who the heck designed the installation?
 

If you need to find a tradesperson to get your job done, please try our local search below, or if you are doing it yourself you can find suppliers local to you.

Select the supplier or trade you require, enter your location to begin your search.


Are you a trade or supplier? You can create your listing free at DIYnot Local

 
Back
Top