Could other people have done a better job than Reeves to date? I don't doubt it.
Could other political parties have done a better job over the past year or so? Possibly.
However all of this ties in with the point we've made on here recently. None of them are having an honest upfront conversation with the public about what really needs to happen (tax take wise etc) to balance the books, genuinely improve services etc. They're not having that conversation with us (any of them) because the truth would hurt. Combined with the fact they're always vying for votes.
Heck, if you were tasked with defending Starmer and Reeves you could assert they have, in part at least, been trying to tell us how it is. e.g. Starmer saying 'it'll get worse before it gets better.' However we don't really want to here that, do we?
The whole system is fecked. Party A in for x years getting some stuff right, some wrong. Party B gets in, getting some stuff right, some wrong. And round and round it goes, with them all blaming each other whilst real, consistent, solid improvements seem to remain a distant dream.