No. The problem is, fan operation. My bedroom is next to the bathroom. During the night I don't want the fan whirring and making noise if I have to make a midnight pee. I also like to have the fan off when I have a bath. It's nice to relax without the whirring. I wanted to turn the fan off if necessary but to wire the fan so that it would come on with the light as default position. My worry is that if it is not wired to the lights and operated independently on another switch the fan would not be on enough. I would always forget to put it on. Your previous solution looks workable though. Cheers.