I
imamartian
... it was a shot at goal, so other players not in play... and it hit a Chelsea player, before rebounding to Ribery.... off a Chelsea player... so no offside !!!!
I'm still glad Chelsea won though !!!
Do you have a clip ?
If he was in an offisde position and 'gaining an advantage' then it does not matter if the ball came from a Chelsea player.
Shot at goal you can be still be offside away from the ball if pulling a defender /gk away or in the GK's way .
If you are in an offside position before the shot is taken, and that
position allows you to score form a rebound or deflection, then you are offside.
Have a mooch through these -
http://www.fifa.com/mm/document/afdeveloping/refereeing/law_11_offside_en_47383.pdf
However, these are split second decsions by officials and pundits have the luxury of umpteen angles at their leisure.
Handball - it's got to be a case of 'handles the ball deliberately'.
no clip, sorry...great post though.. i thought a player "not interfereing with play" was ok..... and a rebound to him was also ok?
