• Looking for a smarter way to manage your heating this winter? We’ve been testing the new Aqara Radiator Thermostat W600 to see how quiet, accurate and easy it is to use around the home. Click here read our review.

Correct use of automatic transmissions

The MB to which the OP refers has the model number W202; it will have a torque-converter automatic transmission.

I agree with much of what "avocet" has written but have the following thoughts based on my own experience of an MB with a 'torque converter'.

I had a W203 with a torque converter and covered 198,000 miles with no problems from the torque converter, admittedly with many long journeys. Also, I manually shifted the gears only when necessary for overtaking or going down steep hills (IMO this prolongs the gearbox life).

If I was going to stop for more than a few seconds, I put the transmission in neutral; if this was in daytime, I put my foot on the brake pedal; if it was night-time, I used the parking brake (to avoid dazzling following drivers).

By putting the transmission in neutral, the ATF is not subjected to unnecessary use and this prolongs it's life. (NB: A torque converter and gearbox should be serviced in accordance with the manufacturer's recommendations, including ATF change and filter change; this is often overlooked.)

The parking brake (the small pedal that is pushed down with one's left foot) mechanism on an MB is a maintenance headache (I know this because I paid the bills time and time again) and I always avoided using it except when necessary.

If the car is stationary in Drive and held on the foot brake (not the parking brake), there is a risk of the foot slipping off the brake pedal if the car is 'rear ended'; also, sitting in the car with the foot pressed on the foot-brake causes back pain if the driver is prone to it.

If the car is stationary and in Park, there is a risk of damage to the gearbox if the car is 'rear-ended).

Finally, regarding the OP's other comment, a torque converter (and probably DSG and CVT), should also be put in Park (not N) and the parking brake / handbrake applied before opening the driver's door. This was not done by a driver a few years ago (the car was in N), and the car rolled back and killed a passing jogger (it was on the south coast somewhere and no doubt some forum members will remember the full details).
 
The MB to which the OP refers has the model number W202; it will have a torque-converter automatic transmission.

I agree with much of what "avocet" has written but have the following thoughts based on my own experience of an MB with a 'torque converter'.

I had a W203 with a torque converter and covered 198,000 miles with no problems from the torque converter, admittedly with many long journeys. Also, I manually shifted the gears only when necessary for overtaking or going down steep hills (IMO this prolongs the gearbox life).

If I was going to stop for more than a few seconds, I put the transmission in neutral; if this was in daytime, I put my foot on the brake pedal; if it was night-time, I used the parking brake (to avoid dazzling following drivers).

By putting the transmission in neutral, the ATF is not subjected to unnecessary use and this prolongs it's life. (NB: A torque converter and gearbox should be serviced in accordance with the manufacturer's recommendations, including ATF change and filter change; this is often overlooked.)

The parking brake (the small pedal that is pushed down with one's left foot) mechanism on an MB is a maintenance headache (I know this because I paid the bills time and time again) and I always avoided using it except when necessary.

If the car is stationary in Drive and held on the foot brake (not the parking brake), there is a risk of the foot slipping off the brake pedal if the car is 'rear ended'; also, sitting in the car with the foot pressed on the foot-brake causes back pain if the driver is prone to it.

If the car is stationary and in Park, there is a risk of damage to the gearbox if the car is 'rear-ended).

Finally, regarding the OP's other comment, a torque converter (and probably DSG and CVT), should also be put in Park (not N) and the parking brake / handbrake applied before opening the driver's door. This was not done by a driver a few years ago (the car was in N), and the car rolled back and killed a passing jogger (it was on the south coast somewhere and no doubt some forum members will remember the full details).


I do wonder though, (but have absolutely no facts, either way!) whether its overall better to leave the torque converter working (as you say, giving the transmission fluid a slightly harder time), or suffering the increased contamination of that same fluid with more clutch band particles by taking it in and out of gear?

I agree with all the other stuff though. With modern cars, it's becoming increasingly common for the airbag sensor to talk to the ABS pump, so that as soon as it detects a collision, it rams the hydraulic brakes on, whether the driver's foot is on the pedal or not.

Onn the last, tragic paragraph, Our DSG car will beep at you if you open the driver's door and it's not in "Park".
 
I do wonder though, (but have absolutely no facts, either way!) whether its overall better to leave the torque converter working (as you say, giving the transmission fluid a slightly harder time), or suffering the increased contamination of that same fluid with more clutch band particles by taking it in and out of gear?

I agree with all the other stuff though. With modern cars, it's becoming increasingly common for the airbag sensor to talk to the ABS pump, so that as soon as it detects a collision, it rams the hydraulic brakes on, whether the driver's foot is on the pedal or not.

Onn the last, tragic paragraph, Our DSG car will beep at you if you open the driver's door and it's not in "Park".
Most mercedes will automatically put the transmission into park if you open the door.

Very awkward if you want to look out the bottom of the door if you want to manoeuvre onto a narrow ramp etc
 
Back
Top