Difficulty controlling hot water temperature

Joined
23 Mar 2008
Messages
34
Reaction score
1
Location
Warwickshire
Country
United Kingdom
I have just fitted a Techflow QT120 twin shower pump in the loft. Before anyone tells me I know Techflow dont recomend it and its not the best place for shower pumps.

Initially I thought the problem of poor pressure on the pumped hot side side was down to the pump being installed in the loft and air getting into the pump. After chasing my tail on this theory and fitting an ESSEX type flange (techflange from Techflow), an Anti gravity loop, manual vents on the hot inlet to the pump and a bottle vent on the hot output of the pump I came to the conclusion this wasnt the problem.

To prove this I purged the shower pump and pipe work of air when the hot water cyslinder was full of cold water and then tried the shower on full hot. With this I had good pressure on the hot side of the pump - same as on the cold side.

I therefore decide the problem could be down to the hot water being do hot causing cavitation in the pump. The cylinder stat was set at 60degrees but to be honest the water has always been too hot. I emptied the hot water tank and then turned the stat down to 50 degrees to try the pump at this temperature. The problem was the water remained just as hot.

Before people start suggesting the thermosat is faulty or the mid position valve is faulty they are not. I have changed them both as a precautionary measure and checked the mid position valve and thermostat operate (as per a Y plan system). They oprate as they should, but the cyslinder thermostat seems to register a much lower temperature than the water in the cylinder. The cylinder thermostat is a Honeywell strap on type that is mounted 1/3 the way up the cylinder as is normal. It has good contact with the cylinder which is nice and shiny copper. Through tweaking the thermostat, I have found that setting it to 40-45 degrees yeilds a water temperature in the range of 60-65 degrees. This is acheived when the boiler thermostat is set on 4 (approx 71 degress according to the manual).

I have wondered if it is worth moving the thermostat further up the cylinder, but then I wont get a call for heat until the water at that level is 'cool' an so coudl end up with less hot water capacity?

I have also wondered if the issue is because the cylinder thermostat is located between the coil inlet/outlets on the cylinder?

Is it normal for the cylinder stat to be so far out compared to the water temperature?

The only option I can see is to set the water temp by trial and error - ignoring the actual temp on the thermostat scale. Or fit a thermostat probe that takes the water temp directly - that is if you can retrofit them somehow to a cylinder without a suitable boss?

Any suggestions are welcome. This is driving me insane.
 
Sponsored Links
Most, if not all shower pump problems are installation, it's got to be a 'text book' installation to work correctly. Back to basics matey!!!
 
Cylinder stat issue.

The position you note is normal, the inaccuracy of the stats operation is also normal. most of the mechanical stats of this type have an operating differential of approx 12c. ie +/- 6c from the set mark. The location of the stat on a cylinder will mean that the output temp is often in excess of the set temp due to stratification of the water collum.

To achieve a maximum temp that you feel is safe for you and yours some adjustment is required using trial and error or a thermometer.

Shower Issue

If I understand correctly you can not achieve the desired temp from the shower in spite of the hot water temp be available?

You do not say but is the shower unit a thermostatic model?

If so perhaps the showers maximum temp limit needs adjustment as many units do in fact prevent excessive temps to avoid the chance of scolding, these sometimes are not correctly set by manufacturer or perhaps it has inadvertently been miss set by persons investigating the valve?

hope that helps
 

DIYnot Local

Staff member

If you need to find a tradesperson to get your job done, please try our local search below, or if you are doing it yourself you can find suppliers local to you.

Select the supplier or trade you require, enter your location to begin your search.


Are you a trade or supplier? You can create your listing free at DIYnot Local

 
Sponsored Links
Back
Top