Rip out old ceiling or batten over?

[hampshire_rob]

Hi there,

I've moved a loft hatch from the bathroom (stupid place) to the hall. When I say 'moved', the old hatch is still in the bathroom, accompanied by a very tatty plaster boarded ceiling.

Question is this:

Do I batten (1 inch) over the existing mess and lay fresh board on top for skimming?

or,

Do I remove all the old board and hatch architrave, re-board and skim?

Is there a chance of moisture getting trapped in the cavity with the first option? Also, I'm having recessed downlights. Will they generate an unsafe amount of heat in the cavity?

Many Thanks

 

[Zampa]

I would go for the batten everytime...ive only taken down one ceiling and beleive me its a very dirty messy job...you'l be sweeping up dust for weeks.

The moisture in the void wont be a problem...as for the heat from the lights..that shouldnt be a problem either, thats what those tpye of lights are for afterall...but I think you can buy fireproof shrouds for extra peace of mind.

 

[grrinc]

If its plasterboard, then simply nail your new plaster board directly over it. Make sure you use the correct length nails though. I have only stripped a few ceilings back in my time - it was a filthy old day and I am always looking to avoid doing it now.

 

[Nige F]

I`d batten and pack aswell so it`s all level

 

[hampshire_rob]

Thanks for the advice.

Batten and board it is then.