Tax free cash ISA allowance to be cut

[Mottie]

No. That's just bragging and rubbing salt into salty (Brexit) 'winners'.

It’s retrospective bragging without any proof that he owned them. Stop trying to defend the indefensible.

 

[denso13]

It’s retrospective bragging without any proof that he owned them. Stop trying to defend the indefensible.

It isn't against the rules.

If you are arguing that everyone should post proof of anything they post then let's try that.

 

[Justin Passing]

"The posts have been deleted" I see you both bleat.
Pathetic.

You've disgraced yoursefl enough, surely? No we are not "bleating",

I've had posts removed, but you've moaned more so we can assume you've had a share deleted as well..
If I remember posting something and cant find it, it's sometimes the Search function being flaky, or I get the terms wrong.
I don't know if those with certain privileges can find deleted posts. Hey we could ask the mods.
I daresay JD is better at it, he's been here since way before I arrived.

I remembered "64%", but I didn't find anything. I tried again. I did not find the source of the more recent post..
I gave JD a chance, but he's not answering, because he can't. He maybe did a search and found ...something
You would expect him to look, wouldn't you?
But then you'd expect him to be honest, too.

That's funny, I thought, did that just pop up?

 

[Mottie]

It isn't against the rules.

I didn’t say it was. Nobody has. I said it was retrospective bragging without proof that he actually owned any.

 

[Mottie]

Serious question Mottie - what exactly am I defending?

JohnD's retrospective bragging without proof. His brag was made retrospectively in 2020, not in advance in 2016. I could say I bought bitcoins for tuppence each when they first came out….

 

[denso13]

I could say I bought bitcoins for tuppence each when they first came out….

And I'd say good for you.

Not, "prove it or you are a devious scumbag liar". It's not that important surely?

His brag was made retrospectively in 2020, not in advance in 2016

So what? No one died.

 

[Mottie]

So what? No one died.

But someone lied. I've lost count of the times I’ve claimed something on here and straight away the screams I get back mainly from remainers is "anecdotal, doesn’t count, we want proof"!

 

[Mottie]

I'm not questioning the veracity of JD's bragging, merely questioning the fact that he has been accused of xy and z, without any substance.

So far all he has claimed is that he has made far more money shifting his investments out of the UK into Europe post Brexit and has given some vague random numbers along with it. Sems to me like an awful lot of bitterness and jealousy from you, Justin and MBK.

Yawn. Okay, if that’s what you want but don’t any of you ever ask for 'proof' next time someone posts something that contradicts your viewpoint.

 

[denso13]

But someone lied.

Well you think he did.

Okay, if that’s what you want but don’t any of you ever ask for 'proof' next time someone posts something that contradicts your viewpoint.

Asking for it is fine, but if someone declines then there is no more you can do. It's a witch hunt for some reason.

 

[Mottie]

JD posted up this...
I am an investor, not a trader. I do not seek excitement. Nor daily effort.

You will be disappointed to hear that FEV is only up another 21% in the past year.

One of my other biggest long-term holdings is up 64% in 12 months, but IMO it is now overvalued, and riskier because it is now overly concentrated in a single business, so I have halved it. Perhaps I will look back and see I got out too soon. Better than being too late.

Nothing else remarkable happening.

and also this...
That's sad.

As an anti-Brexer, I naturally moved most of my pension and other nest egg into European and International sectors.

I believe Rees-Mogg and his buddies did something similar. Perhaps they didn't believe the lies they told.

I see FEV is up 40% since the 2016 referendum, having fallen 12% since 1 Jan.

What else do you want? If you disbelieve him, then that's fine. If you, Justin or MBK have evidence to the contrary and think that he is a liar - post it up boyos, the floor is yours.

You going into repeat repeat mode again?

No

What is the matter with you?

Post # 195 and post # 235. JD has claimed exactly what he stated here...

I am an investor, not a trader. I do not seek excitement. Nor daily effort.

You will be disappointed to hear that FEV is only up another 21% in the past year.

One of my other biggest long-term holdings is up 64% in 12 months, but IMO it is now overvalued, and riskier because it is now overly concentrated in a single business, so I have halved it. Perhaps I will look back and see I got out too soon. Better than being too late.
Nothing else remarkable happening.

and also this...
That's sad.

As an anti-Brexer, I naturally moved most of my pension and other nest egg into European and International sectors.

I believe Rees-Mogg and his buddies did something similar. Perhaps they didn't believe the lies they told.
I see FEV is up 40% since the 2016 referendum, having fallen 12% since 1 Jan.

Apologise to whom and for what? You are sounding like a disturbed jealous nutter.

 

[Justin Passing]

To whom and for what?

where's the instrument he made 64% on?

 

[Mottie]

They can't. They won't.

Jealousy and bitterness.

Jealous? Of a sad, lonely old fun sponge? Nah!

 

[Justin Passing]

You want a poster that makes shrewd investments to give DIYnot the heads up, the instant he makes an investment?

He sure as hell shouldn't just say "I made load of money because I'm a pious INVESTOR not a paltry trader" - which he implies.

Only a $h1t does that.

He can say what it was later. Nobody nobody nobody is suggesting the stupidity you set out. Straw man lying behaviour.
Troll reported.
Depends which mod sees it I guess.
It could be the one who was fully exposed in the open forum because he posted in the combustion chamber , where only a mod would be able to access without being a gas man.
Gasser named him.

 

[Mottie]

It could be the one who was fully exposed in the open forum because he posted in the combustion chamber , where only a mod would be able to access without being a gas man.
Gasser named him.

Yeah, I remember that episode.

 

[Justin Passing]

Eh? JD wrote the post did he not? FFS lad, make some sense.

I say again, if you have evidence that JD lied about his investment, mislead folk about his investments, gave out false information - post it up.

You said "JD posted up" as though he was admitting it now. He did't he was shown up by his silence.

Just read it. , it's simple in the contex of this thread. I did not say he lied about his investment, only that he concealed it which is asking for trouble. I've been asking him for days if he did that, which he should have used as a hint and answer it. That's what I meant when Isaid I was trying to help him. He's bright enough to see that even if..... some are not.

Justin too likes to share his financial gains. I have no reason to disbelieve what he posts.

But I say what it was and how you too can do the same. I've said how in advance as well. Different altogether. If you're telling us you can't the difference, you're not being honest, are you?
This is just more trolling

"you, MBK and Mottie are persecuting him for personal details?"
They aren't personal details, . The answer might be "it was oil shares" . What's personal about that?
Nothing/If he's been clever, fine. If he wanted it secret, than the world would be better off including him, if he's STFU.

We just want the bloke, and you, to be open and honest. Not what we're seeing.