What Boiler Type - Systems or Combi

Joined
4 Nov 2026
Messages
3
Reaction score
1
Country
United Kingdom
Hi, welcome any insight on replacement boiler type for our standard 4 bedroom 2 bathrooms (incl 1 en-suite shower ) house. Currently got a Homeflow Unvented Cylinder upstairs with a Logic Heat 18 Boiler in the garage. Its 12 years old, had a few issues and our plumber has suggested its getting to the point we should think about replacing it. Fine. But then complicated the decision by suggesting alternatively he could strip out the whole system and replace it with a simple combi boiler. About the same price. He has not really given any conclusive argument one way or the other. Just said that for 2 people in a house this size we dont need such a large complex system solution and a combi would work just fine. Welcome any views on why we should change a system tahts largely worked fine for 12 years. Appreciate your time on this
 
I now have solar, batteries, and off-peak electric supply, and I have very cheap domestic hot water (DHW) I was lucky enough to still have a cylinder, otherwise I could have not used either solar or off-peak to heat DHW, so unless you have a really good reason to get rid of a cylinder, I would keep it.
 
Thanks for your time guys. That was my inclination but now far more confident having seen your replies
 
Thanks for your time guys. That was my inclination but now far more confident having seen your replies
What are the issues with the logic. Has this boiler been serviced correctly.
Just because it is 12 years old is NO reason it be replaced.
What size combi was the repairer suggesting.

Know someone whose boiler was replaced with a BIG output combi. Gas line is undersized for the new combi boiler- go figure
 
Maybe get a 2nd opinion on the Ideal or fixed price repair from Ideal?
 
  • Like
Reactions: DP
I am wholly clueless on this but the Logic is leaking water. Understand there is a component that collects steam and extracts it via a pipe. Plumber replaced a small plastic seal as a instant fix but leak has returned. Not got into specifics on a replacement combi. It has been serviced annually tho not by the same company & i could not swear to the quality. Does feel like we have jumped quite quickly to "get a new one" for £2800.
 
Plumber replaced a small plastic seal as a instant fix but leak has returned.
Plumber should fix it then really, but I wouldn’t want them back.
Does feel like we have jumped quite quickly to "get a new one" for £2800.
Exactly, parts are available, depending on which ones obviously depends on cost, but cheaper than £2800 and so would Ideal on a fixed price repair at £359.
 
Sounds like you have the classic cracked sump on a logic not really an expensive repair and pretty straight forward .
aLso if your happy with existing set up i would not go the combi route when a straight forward boiler change would be far cheaper and what you are used to
.
 
......until it goes wrong. Then it's likely to be harder to diagnose and fix. Better to replace with another heat-only boiler.
combis are an absolute doddle to diagnose and repair
 

If you need to find a tradesperson to get your job done, please try our local search below, or if you are doing it yourself you can find suppliers local to you.

Select the supplier or trade you require, enter your location to begin your search.


Are you a trade or supplier? You can create your listing free at DIYnot Local

 
Back
Top