stupid question - infraRed

My main gripe with infrared heating is it only heats what it illuminates and then not everything.
As an example in a farm building with no insulation, used as panel building workshop; my back and ears would be toasty warm but my hands and the kit i'm working on are freezing cold.
 
My main gripe with infrared heating is it only heats what it illuminates and then not everything.
Sure, but what you are calling a reason for 'gripe' is what others might, in some circumstances, regard as the 'great advantage' of radiant heating - as your own example really goes on to illustrate ...
As an example in a farm building with no insulation, used as panel building workshop; my back and ears would be toasty warm but my hands and the kit i'm working on are freezing cold.
The cost difference between trying to heat all of the air in "a farm building with no insulation" and heating just a person within it must be very dramatic.

However, because of the issue you mention, and contrary to what eric suggested, to have a single IR heater 'high up' is not a very clever idea, since the heating will then be primarily of the top of the head and shoulders of the person 'illuminated'. Far better to have the radiant heaters fairly 'low down', and to have at least a couple (ideally more), 'illuminating' different parts of a person.

It's nothing new. At least some of us are old enough to remember the days when we huddled in front of an electric 'bar heater' or paraffin 'radiant heater' (both of which relied primarily on heating by radiation) - with scorching hot faces, chests and hands but freezing cold backs :) Indeed, that even happens with the likes of coal fires, unless/until they have been going for long enough to significantly heat the air in the room.

Kind Regards, John
 
In my experience IR heater low down are less effective due to obstructions, I usually find the 'floor standing' versions standing on something like a table etc.
 
Sure, but what you are calling a reason for 'gripe' is what others might, in some circumstances, regard as the 'great advantage' of radiant heating - as your own example really goes on to illustrate ...
The cost difference between trying to heat all of the air in "a farm building with no insulation" and heating just a person within it must be very dramatic.
Kind Regards, John
Indeed but very often these 'ad hoc' situations spring up with very little control. For example when working at Royal Chelsea Hospital the basement space made available to me as a workshop basically had an open arch as means of access on one side and multiple large openings on the opposite side, this was on opposite sides of the very large building so there was a permanent cold wind blowing through even in the summer when i was working there.
 
In my experience IR heater low down are less effective due to obstructions, I usually find the 'floor standing' versions standing on something like a table etc.
Yep, I agree - as I implied, the ideal is (two or more) at 'person level' (not 'high up and pointing down, which one often sees).

Kind Regards, John
 
Indeed but very often these 'ad hoc' situations spring up with very little control. For example when working at Royal Chelsea Hospital the basement space made available to me as a workshop basically had an open arch as means of access on one side and multiple large openings on the opposite side, this was on opposite sides of the very large building so there was a permanent cold wind blowing through even in the summer when i was working there.
Fair enough, but what would be your solution to that? - surely not to attempt to heat all the air in a "very large building [with] a permanent cold wind blowing through it" ?!

"Gripe" or not, attempts at IR heating (of yourself) would seem the least of the evils in that situation, wouldn't it?

Kind Regards, John
 
Yep, I agree - as I implied, the ideal is (two or more) at 'person level' (not 'high up and pointing down, which one often sees).

Kind Regards, John
I think the important part is limiting the distance (within reason of course, after all we don't want to be preparing our bodies for dinner) and shadows between heater and person.
 
Fair enough, but what would be your solution to that? - surely not to attempt to heat all the air in a "very large building [with] a permanent cold wind blowing through it" ?!

"Gripe" or not, attempts at IR heating (of yourself) would seem the least of the evils in that situation, wouldn't it?

Kind Regards, John
Just explaining why some venues are less than ideal as work places. Yes IR could very well be a good option there.
 
Just explaining why some venues are less than ideal as work places. Yes IR could very well be a good option there.
Quite - that was my point. As I said, in the situation you describe, IR could well be the least of the evils.

Kind Regards, John
 

If you need to find a tradesperson to get your job done, please try our local search below, or if you are doing it yourself you can find suppliers local to you.

Select the supplier or trade you require, enter your location to begin your search.


Are you a trade or supplier? You can create your listing free at DIYnot Local

 
Back
Top