Are all British citizens British?

Notch7 · 2025-12-31T07:37:29+0000

Here is somebody who says not necessarily

SPLINE · 2025-12-31T07:41:40+0000

If Abdul in the video is English, Joanne Lumley is a Pakistani.

motorbiking · 2025-12-31T09:20:12+0000

The key phrase "I don't identify as English"

Notch7 · 2025-12-31T09:27:42+0000

motorbiking said:
The key phrase "I don't identify as English"

is that for him to decide or other people?

Do you think that anybody not Caucasian looking is not British?

Notch7 · 2025-12-31T09:28:54+0000

SPLINE said:
If Abdul in the video is English, Joanne Lumley is a Pakistani.

why?

do you think that only Caucasian looking people can be British?

MNW67 · 2025-12-31T09:31:22+0000

Notch7 said:
why?

do you think that only Caucasian looking people can be British?

I'm a bit confused by the point you are raising.

The white guy in the video says the other guy is British. Just not English. Whatever that means to him.

motorbiking · 2025-12-31T09:31:52+0000

Notch7 said:
is that for him to decide or other people?

Do you identify as English. If so why?

Notch7 said:
Do you think that anybody not Caucasian looking is not British?

that would include me.

Notch7 · 2025-12-31T09:34:33+0000

motorbiking said:
Do you identify as English. If so why?

I dont "identify" as anybody

I am British because I am a British citizen

motorbiking said:
that would include me

you havent answered the question

Do you think anybody not Caucasian looking is not British?

motorbiking · 2025-12-31T09:36:10+0000

Notch7 said:
I dont "identify" as anybody

I am British because I am a British citizen

you didn't answer.

motorbiking said:
Do you identify as English. If so why?

Notch7 said:
you havent answered the question

Do you think anybody not Caucasian looking is not British?

obviously not.

richw · 2025-12-31T09:43:26+0000

Isn't it the difference between a piece of paper and ethnicity?

I could follow the process to live in China and gain citizenship. Does that make me Chinese? No - I am English. If I had a child over there, with my English wife, the child might get some Chinese documents, but won't be Chinese. If I had a child with an ethnically Chinese lady, then that child would have some Chinese ethnicity.

SPLINE · 2025-12-31T22:21:04+0000

Conversations that cannot be had on the telly...

MNW67 · 2026-01-01T03:02:04+0000

Is he really talking about deporting every Jew from the UK? What a prat.

This is what the interviewer, who is Jewish, wrote at the top of the comments on YT:

My family has been in the UK since pre-1900. Do you think I should be DEPORTED? Racists will hijack the comments. It always happens with purity spirals. But do any of you - who are with me about mass immigration, Islamism and anti-whiteness - also stand against the rhetoric that would deport blacks, Jews and other races/ethnicities solely due to their blood? Where is your line in the sand?

SPLINE · 2026-01-01T04:13:31+0000

MNW67 said:
Is he really talking about deporting every Jew from the UK? What a prat.

Yes, he is. That is not my view though - I don't know why people dislike Jews. Steve Laws wants all people who are not of English ehnicity removing from England, on the very reasonable premise that we are being replaced in our own country and have no other country to escape to, whereas any immigrant to England can go back to his own country.

That video was an excerpt from a longer interview. The purpose of the excerpt was to show the part where Steve Laws tells the show's host, Andrew Gold, directly that he (Laws) wants him (Gold) deporting, which has caused a bit of a stir. Laws is not singling out Jews; he wants all non-English ethnic removing, and interestingly, he has a deportation plan, which other politicians (with the exception of Rupert Lowe) do not have.

MNW67 · 2026-01-01T09:30:28+0000

SPLINE said:
Yes, he is. That is not my view though - I don't know why people dislike Jews. Steve Laws wants all people who are not of English ehnicity removing from England, on the very reasonable premise that we are being replaced in our own country and have no other country to escape to, whereas any immigrant to England can go back to his own country.

That video was an excerpt from a longer interview. The purpose of the excerpt was to show the part where Steve Laws tells the show's host, Andrew Gold, directly that he (Laws) wants him (Gold) deporting, which has caused a bit of a stir. Laws is not singling out Jews; he wants all non-English ethnic removing, and interestingly, he has a deportation plan, which other politicians (with the exception of Rupert Lowe) do not have.

You're playing fast and loose with the meaning of the word 'interestingly'. And the word 'plan'.

carmanmemoranda · 2026-01-01T10:03:31+0000

SPLINE said:
Yes, he is. That is not my view though - I don't know why people dislike Jews. Steve Laws wants all people who are not of English ehnicity removing from England, on the very reasonable premise that we are being replaced in our own country and have no other country to escape to, whereas any immigrant to England can go back to his own country.

That video was an excerpt from a longer interview. The purpose of the excerpt was to show the part where Steve Laws tells the show's host, Andrew Gold, directly that he (Laws) wants him (Gold) deporting, which has caused a bit of a stir. Laws is not singling out Jews; he wants all non-English ethnic removing, and interestingly, he has a deportation plan, which other politicians (with the exception of Rupert Lowe) do not have.

Have you actually thought his "thoughts" through ?

Define exactly what "not of English ethnicity " means.

Scottish for example ? Mixed parentage? People born here to people who have settled 5 or so generations ago and are settled in.?

It's just a lot of hot air for the easily led.

Like you. Farage fodder

Are all British citizens British?

Similar threads