A plumber and trainee plasterer beats Labour and Reform

JP_

Joined
17 May 2012
Messages
11,379
Reaction score
1,002
Country
United Kingdom
Will plumbers and other trades unite under the new banner to make Britain great again?


Is Reform mistaken in thinking it only needs to beat Labour to win the next general election? Maybe the old industriial cities and London will look to the Greens in the election. Most interesting is the poor performance of the Lib Dems. You'd think this was their opportunity.

Some analysis:

The 2026 Gorton and Denton by-election, held on February 26, resulted in a historic victory for the Green Party, marking their first-ever parliamentary by-election win. Hannah Spencer, a local plumber and councillor, overturned a 13,000-vote Labour majority to become the party’s first MP in the North of England.

Vote Counts and Results

The result was a significant upset, with Labour collapsing into third place—the first time the party has placed third in a seat it was defending since 1982.

CandidatePartyVotesShareChange (from 2024)
Hannah SpencerGreen Party14,98040.7%+27.5%
Matt GoodwinReform UK10,57828.7%+14.6%
Angeliki StogiaLabour9,36425.4%-25.4%
Charlotte CaddenConservative7061.9%-6.0%
Jackie PearceyLib Dem6531.8%-2.0%


Analysis of the Outcome

1. Turnout comparison
Turnout was 47.6%, which is exceptionally high for a by-election. It was almost identical to the 2024 general election turnout of 47.8% (a negligible drop of 0.2 percentage points). This suggests the Green victory wasn't just due to "normal" voters staying home, but rather a high level of engagement and a massive shift in preference among those who did vote.
2. Did Labour lose support or did Greens gain new voters?
It was a combination of both:

  • Labour's Collapse: Labour's vote share plummeted by 25.4%. Analysts and party insiders pointed to local anger over the national leadership's stance on Gaza and the controversial decision by the NEC to block Greater Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham from standing as the candidate.
  • Green Surge: The Greens ran an energetic campaign focused on local issues and "anti-establishment" sentiment. They achieved a massive 27.5% swing, positioning themselves as the primary "progressive" alternative to Labour.
3. Reform UK's Progress
Reform UK made significant progress, finishing in second place with 28.7% of the vote—nearly doubling their 2024 share. While they did not win, their performance confirmed their status as a major force in traditionally "safe" Labour heartlands. Candidate Matt Goodwin (a political scientist and pundit) outperformed the Labour candidate, though he later faced criticism for claiming the Green win was a result of "sectarian politics."

What happened?

The by-election was triggered by the resignation of Andrew Gwynne on health grounds. The resulting race became a "three-way showdown." The combination of a deeply unpopular central government, local friction over candidate selection, and a highly effective "ground war" by Green volunteers led to what John Curtice described as a "seismic" result in British politics.
 
The Green Party won on the strength of the muslim vote. Nothing to do with green issues or the working classes.
Or is it because not everybody wants Reform ... many people feel they are too right wing, too anti immigration, and frankly, a bit racist.

Not so much as "muslim vote", something only Reform are saying, but more a "we don't want racists to run our town" vote.

Or, maybe, working class people just want a working class person to represent them, and see through the lies of grifters like Nigel Farage and Tommy Robinson, who pretent to be with the people, but are really just in it for the dosh. And Matt Goodwin is far from working class too.
 
The turnout for a by election was extremely high.

It would be interesting to find out what motivated voters to come out and vote.

A lot of Muslims probably wanted to give Labour a black eye over Gaza.

A lot of more right wing voters probably sniffed the chance of a Reform upset.

The Tory and Lib Dem vote collapsed.
 
Back
Top