Why buy an old style hot water system which can "run out of hot water"?

Joined
23 Mar 2007
Messages
116
Reaction score
2
Location
Cheshire
Country
United Kingdom
My whole life I've lived in places in which the water was heated on demand so there was never such an issue as running out of hot water. I was aware of such systems that heated a lot of water at once and could run out of that hot water but I thought they were just antiquated systems that had not yet been replaced. My friend recently moved into a brand new house fitted with a system of the kind that runs out of water. Why are these even being built still??
 
Sponsored Links
Does he have a white hot-water cylinder?

How big is it?

Does he have a bath, or two shower-rooms?

The short answer is "because they're very good."
 
Does he have a white hot-water cylinder?

How big is it?

Does he have a bath, or two shower-rooms?

The short answer is "because they're very good."

In what way are they very good? Are they more energy efficient? Cheaper to install and/or maintain?

I think they have two bathrooms but I don't know what facilities are in each. I don't know the specifics of the hot water system either.
 
They only "run out of water" if they are incorrectly sized for the property. They also have the distinct advantage that they can (usually) be independently heated if there is a problem with the boiler, can deliver a higher flow rate & a higher temperature than a combi-boiler/instantaneous heater.

Wait until you've got a house full of people all wanting hot water at the same time and see if that changes your view.
 
Sponsored Links
My whole life I've lived in places in which the water was heated on demand
Such installations are limited to a single outlet, and are therefore useless where two or more bathrooms are fitted.
They are incapable of supplying high flow rates, such as you would want when filling a large bath.
 
Because these systems often have a backup heating system (immersion) built in. If the boiler breaks you can still get hot water.

If your on demand system fails you've got nothing until it gets fixed.
 
when I used to visit my Aunt and cousins, and spend the night over, in the morning she would say to me if I want to take a bath can I please wait for an hour as someone just had a bath and the hot water has run out! crazy!
 
Shouldn't make any difference, reheat time of a modern unvented is around 20 minutes after drawing off 70% of the volume
Typically yes but when it is a large cylinder ( vented or unvented ) and a low power boiler then re-heat can be considerably longer.
 
when I used to visit my Aunt and cousins, and spend the night over, in the morning she would say to me if I want to take a bath can I please wait for an hour as someone just had a bath and the hot water has run out! crazy!
Classic case of am undersized cylinder, or possibly an electrically heated one as they heat up much more slowly
 
Shouldn't make any difference, reheat time of a modern unvented is around 20 minutes after drawing off 70% of the volume
Typically yes but when it is a large cylinder ( vented or unvented ) and a low power boiler then re-heat can be considerably longer.
So in situations where the system hasn't been correctly specified, it doesn't work as it should? Wow, there's a surprise o_O
 
So in situations where the system hasn't been correctly specified, it doesn't work as it should? Wow, there's a surprise o_O

Maybe the time to re-heat has been specified as one hour. That would allow for a lower heat output boiler to be specified. It could more efficient and cost effective to then specify a boiler whose maximum output matches the peak central heating load. This maximum output might be less than the output necessary for a 20 minutes reheat cylinder . Running a High output boiler for 20 minutes may or may not be as efficient as running a boiler 1/3 of the output for 60 minutes.
 
Bernard, if you were a farmer, would you buy a tractor with a lawn mower engine as that engine could use flatulance produced by the cows hence would be very economical?

If I am going to buy a Bently would I be looking at the MPG instead of comfort?
 

DIYnot Local

Staff member

If you need to find a tradesperson to get your job done, please try our local search below, or if you are doing it yourself you can find suppliers local to you.

Select the supplier or trade you require, enter your location to begin your search.


Are you a trade or supplier? You can create your listing free at DIYnot Local

 
Sponsored Links
Back
Top