Fibre cement slates....which one... Or reclaimed welsh slate

[b21playa]

Which one would you choose out of cembrit jutland and Marley thrutone?

The marley's are 97p and cembrit are 79p a slate. Both prices for 500x250mm

Too many slates on mine have cracked etc, and neighbours don't want to replace theirs, so need to be able to tie in theirs to mine really without bonding gutter. Would this be possible?

Or should I just try and find proper reclaimed slates to match the ones I have?

 

[shane12345]

Cembrit are perfectly fine, i've used them many times.
You will need a bonding gutter if next door is still the original slate.

Replacement slate is easily available. You will have to weigh up the best option.