# Final proof, The labour party are anti semitic

Discussion in 'General Discussion' started by mwatsonxx, 28 Sep 2017.

1. ### JohnD

Joined:
15 Nov 2005
Messages:
61,518
3,240
Location:
Fife
Country:
It's possible that Doggit actually doesn't understand, in which case someone can surely explain?

Joined:
25 Jan 2017
Messages:
4,738
57
Country:
BnB?

4. ### JohnD

Joined:
15 Nov 2005
Messages:
61,518
3,240
Location:
Fife
Country:
Some animals have four legs.

If I have one horse, two dogs and a cat, I have four animals with four legs

If I have one cat, I have one animal with four legs.

If I have only a budgie, I have no animals with four legs.

If I have only an Arcoptrix, but I have no animals with four legs, then you can deduce that an Archeoptrix is not an animal with four legs.

5. ### IWalkLikeHimaMartian

Joined:
25 Jan 2017
Messages:
4,738
57
Country:
Oh no I can't.
But I can deduce that an Arcoptrix is not an animal with four legs.

6. ### JohnD

Joined:
15 Nov 2005
Messages:
61,518
3,240
Location:
Fife
Country:
Some religions are branches of Christianity.

If a room contains two Catholics, one Methodist, three Baptists and a Sikh, there are six Christians in the room.

If the room contains only three Mazdaznans, I tell you it contains no Christians, you can deduce that Mazdaznans are not Christians.

If it contains three Catholics, and I tell you that there are no Christians, you can deduce that I am lying or mistaken, because Catholics are Christians

7. ### JohnD

Joined:
15 Nov 2005
Messages:
61,518
3,240
Location:
Fife
Country:
The person who drew up the chart claims that some parties contain Catholics, but no Christians.

He is therefore either mistaken, or lying.

Joined:
20 Nov 2009
Messages:
23,055
3,002
Location:
Surrey
Country:
*****
mod
*****

9. ### vinty

The correct term should be anti-Jewish and not anti-Semitic, there are 100's of millions of Semites in the world and most of them are not Jewish.
Most Israelis are of Eastern European origin and have very little genetic connection to the Middle East, although DNA testing has shown that European Jews have some traces of Middle Eastern DNA on the paternal side, the bulk of their DNA is Eastern European mostly from the maternal side and in the Jewish religion it is the maternal side which counts, basically if you have a Jewish mother then you are considered Jewish even if your mother is an atheist or practising another religion.
A few years ago a private Jewish school in the South of England was convicted of racial discrimination and not religious discrimination because they refused entry to the son of a Jewish man and his Catholic wife while allowing entry to the son of a non Jewish man and his wife who had been born Jewish but had been raised a Catholic.

• Thanks x 1
11. ### EFLImpudence

Joined:
7 Jul 2010
Messages:
30,968
3,345
Location:
Retired to:
Country:
Courts make mistakes; probably fuelled by political correctness - assuming, that is, they were not of a different race.

12. ### Doggit

Thank you fo that little piece Vinty; I was aware of the Jewish mother bit, but had no idea on the Semetic aspect of this debate. It's nice to see that someone here can add to the debate, rather than show how clever they are.

13. ### Notch7

Joined:
15 Sep 2017
Messages:
15,868
1,176
Location:
Sussex
Country:
Did Jeremy Corbyn in his keynote peech state categorically he has a zero tolerance for anti-semitism?

It was a perfect opportunity for him to end any media claims of anti-semitism in his party.

14. ### EFLImpudence

Joined:
7 Jul 2010
Messages:
30,968
3,345
Location:
Retired to:
Country:
Then they would have just accused him of lying.

15. ### JohnD

Joined:
15 Nov 2005
Messages:
61,518
3,240
Location:
Fife
Country:
It's interesting that after a long and partially thoughtful discussion, with some good and sensible points, notch woodbine throws in a vague smear to keep the fire smouldering. The very thing that's been commented on.

Yes, this is just a rumour spread by the RWRs because they don't like Labour.

Notch very much among them.

16. ### Notch7

Joined:
15 Sep 2017
Messages:
15,868
1,176
Location:
Sussex
Country:
I merely suggested Jeremy Corbyn had the opportunity to address anti semitism in his keynote speech.

The Jewish chronicle thinks so to

https://www.thejc.com/news/uk-news/...-for-corbyn-to-denounce-antisemitism-1.445282

If its a smear campaign by the RW press, then why did he not even mention it. I would have thought it the perfect opportunity to kill it off stone dead.

17. ### JohnD

Joined:
15 Nov 2005
Messages:
61,518
3,240
Location:
Fife
Country:
I notice that notch has never denied he is Jack the Ripper. Not a single one of his posts contains a condemnation of the murder and mutilation of Victorian prostitutes.

Replies:
32
Views:
704

Replies:
16
Views:
743

Replies:
67
Views:
2,002

Replies:
76
Views:
2,320

Replies:
19
Views:
824

Replies:
0
Views:
528

Replies:
0
Views:
351