Is it worth getting a combi boiler / heat pump?

Joined
11 Oct 2016
Messages
1,011
Reaction score
20
Country
United Kingdom
Hi, I’ve got an ideal Mexico, big thing in the garage , I think there’s a problem with the cylinder at the moment as we are using a lot of water on the meter and our tap water isn’t hot.
I’m wondering whether it’s worth switching to something more efficient rather than repairing what we have?

I’ve heard mixed reviews about both heat pumps and combi s
 
But that "correct design" can mean increasing radiator sizes and adding a lot of insulation, putting the installation cost typically to near £20k. The result may be a saving on energy costs of some £100-200/year (although this is heavily dependent on electricity costs which are only going higher) and you'll need an awful long time to see payback of the installation costs. Also, no-one yet knows how long a lot of heat pumps will last before needing replacement.
 
Combi is suitable for low hot water demand ( small to medium households), Heat pumps need highly insulated property to provide sufficient heat and often solar power to keep running costs low as possible.
Also depends whether you use air source or ground source heat pumps as set up costs vary .
 
Does this include a suitable property?
With the new hi temp heat pumps using the newer refrig fluids then they can run much hotter whilst maintaining their COP 3-4 efficiencies. It means that older less insulated properties can now be retrofitted, existing rads can be retained as system temps can be run hotter maintaining the original deltas and the cylinder can also be retained and be heated from the ASHP directly, to => 60deg, without any supplementary heat source.

Still a seriously significant outlay though and would take a significant period of time to recoup costs...
 
Combi is suitable for low hot water demand ( small to medium households), Heat pumps need highly insulated property to provide sufficient heat and often solar power to keep running costs low as possible.
Also depends whether you use air source or ground source heat pumps as set up costs vary .
Why does everyone think ashps are only suitable for highly insulated properties? We changed a quarter of our radiators. Poorly insulated house. Works fine.

Granted it’s pretty cost neutral energy cost- wise so I wouldn’t install one expecting to save money necessarily (unless you have storage battery to exploit time of use tariffs). Our house has never been more comfortable though and ours is integrated with home assistant so a lot of monitoring and control options.
 
@Madrab has given a good answer, however how the property is used, and what tariff is used, can impact on how well it works, there are special tariffs for heat pumps, but where is all gets muddy is when there is something else also needing a special tariff.

So heat pumps, EVs, Solar panels, batteries, and storage radiators all can benefit from off-peak supplies, but not always the same off-peak tariff. Some give 5 hours, some give 7 hours, some have three stages, some only two, and some have just one cheap slot, and other three cheap slots etc.

And we have seen with storage radiators how the tariffs have changed over the years, so back in the 70s the off-peak was very good, but over the years the rates have changed, so we are taking a gamble on what will happen in the future.

I went from a cylinder for domestic hot water (DHW) to a gas boiler in the last house, as it allowed me to use the room it freed up, it did however have some downsides, it took a lot longer to get hot water to the taps, and any problems with water supply resulted in no stored water, so no water.

As to cost, this house with a cylinder, we are paying far less with an immersion heater to what it would cost using oil. But it depends on the house, mother house boiler right next to kitchen sink, so to that point, got hot water faster. There was a problem with the shower, with it going from cold to hot back to cold and then hot and stay hot, as the reservoir was used up, but with a wet room could easily stand to one side as it warmed up.

Again we use solar here to heat DHW, the regular spikes 1777163015318.png is the immersion turning on to keep the DHW hot, using the solar power, I actually think it would cost less to just use off-peak, but to change the system will cost, so sticking with what I have. I have seen a huge drop in oil use since using the solar, I had no idea how much DHW was costing me.

As to how much it costs for the match with a combi boiler I don't know what I am talking about is cost to fire up the boiler even when no hot water gets to the taps, it is a phrase used with heritage railways, how much it costs to get up steam, even when the engine is not used. But I do not use enough hot water for the water in the pipes to stay hot between each use, so mothers house I would hear the boiler fire up when I turned on the tap, in Eco mode, and I would get half a bowl of water before the hot arrived, I also had to turn on the taps full on, or the boiler would not fire up. And turn Eco mode off, and the boiler would fire up every so often just to keep the reservoir hot. And all the metal in the boiler has to heat up and cool down again, so either way we need some energy just to have DHW avaiable.
 

If you need to find a tradesperson to get your job done, please try our local search below, or if you are doing it yourself you can find suppliers local to you.

Select the supplier or trade you require, enter your location to begin your search.


Are you a trade or supplier? You can create your listing free at DIYnot Local

 
Back
Top