Non-bidirectional RCD/RCBO feeding sockets, should they get a code C2 with EICR?

Joined
27 Jan 2008
Messages
28,643
Reaction score
3,492
Location
Llanfair Caereinion, Nr Welshpool
Country
United Kingdom
It does not matter if, or when the government permits plug and play solar, it seems it is being bought and used anyway.

We have seen the test on a non-bidirectional RCBO, OK needed the test button to be pressed, but with plug and play solar there is a potential danger that the protection device will not work.

So when will we see first complaint about EICR failure as wrong RCBO fitted?
 
We have seen the test on a non-bidirectional RCBO, OK needed the test button to be pressed, but with plug and play solar there is a potential danger that the protection device will not work.
As I've been saying, I currently know nothing that suggests that such would be the case. The only (fairly trivial) 'issue' of which I'm aware relates to the situation when current is flowing through a device in the 'unintended' direction and someone keeps the test button pressed for an appreciable period of time after the device has tripped (which seems extremely improbable).

What makes you think that "there is a potential danger that the protection device will not work" if current is flowing one way through the device?
 
someone keeps the test button pressed for an appreciable period of time
The time the button was pressed with the efixx demo was not excessive. Had it not been during a test, I would have said it was simply a component failure, but it was clear all due to test button being pressed during the reverse flow.

If it was not for plug and play solar, I would say there is no risk. As to get reverse flow, it needs a battery or similar be it EV or solar, and so unless supplying EV or solar the bidirectional is not required.

But with plug and play, anyone could fit it into any 13 amp socket, I know the rules say "Plugs shall not be used for the connection of electrical power generators to socket-outlets." under BS1363-1, but the devices are still being sold in the UK, and we know they are being used, as there are YouTube videos showing it being done.

So with owner occupied homes there is no reason for Plug and Play, it is easy enough to make a proper connection into the system, but with rental we have little or no control of what the tenant may plug in. So there is a potential danger, it seems it did not burst into flames or anything like that, all it did was remove the RCD protection, so unless no RCD protection will attract a code C2 then omnidirectional RCD/RCBO should not either.

So suppose the question is will a lack of RCD protection mean a code C2? If not, then neither will an omnidirectional RCD/RCBO, if yes, then also an omnidirectional RCD/RCBO should attract a C2 code.

Nice one Ed. Bet he did not consider that before his anouncement? But Omar Khayyám in the 11th century worked out, once done, all thy Piety nor Wit, Shall lure it back to cancel half a Line, Nor all thy Tears wash out a Word of it.

So he would need to at least make a public announcement sorry I got it wrong, we can't have plug and play solar, and fast before too many are sold.
 

If you need to find a tradesperson to get your job done, please try our local search below, or if you are doing it yourself you can find suppliers local to you.

Select the supplier or trade you require, enter your location to begin your search.


Are you a trade or supplier? You can create your listing free at DIYnot Local

 
Back
Top