Part P testing

I certainly wouldn't be concerned with a measurable insulation resistance for the entire installation. One new installation recently had an insulation resistance to Earth of about 60 Megohms and rising, and another wired in new I.S. 201 cable (with insulated cpc) gave around 132 Megohms.
Fair enough, I suppose that I was being a bit 'over-dramatic' in what I said (even though most whole-installation IRs of domestic installations I've personally seen have 'been off the top of the scale').

However, I certainly would not be at all comfortable with a whole-installation IR anything remotely as low as 1MΩ (or even 10MΩ), would you?

Kind Regards, John
 
If I had a house stuffed full of appliances and was trying to quickly establish if there was a SC at that moment, I would put the lives together and bell it out to earth.

A small (but passable) number would satisfy me of that.
 
If I had a house stuffed full of appliances and was trying to quickly establish if there was a SC at that moment, I would put the lives together and bell it out to earth. ... A small (but passable) number would satisfy me of that.
Maybe, that's not really the sort of 'IR testing' we're talking about, is it? ... and, in any event, would a protective device not already have 'told you' if there was a short-circuit somewhere>

Kind Regards, John
 
Your sarcasm is on high tonight.
I wasn't intending to be sarcastic, honest!

However, I don't really understand why one would want/need to undertake an IR test to ascertain if an L-E short-circuit was present. What am I missing?

I was commenting about IRs which are "above, but not much above, 1MΩ" - which is obviously very different from a short-circuit.

Kind Regards, John
 
Fair enough, I suppose that I was being a bit 'over-dramatic' in what I said (even though most whole-installation IRs of domestic installations I've personally seen have 'been off the top of the scale').

However, I certainly would not be at all comfortable with a whole-installation IR anything remotely as low as 1MΩ (or even 10MΩ), would you?

Kind Regards, John
There wouldn't necessarily be anything wrong with 10 Megohms. It is really going to depend on the numbers and lengths of circuits involved etc. As I said, it may also be as a result of plaster drying out etc.
 
There wouldn't necessarily be anything wrong with 10 Megohms. It is really going to depend on the numbers and lengths of circuits involved etc.
In terms literally literally of the 'resistance of the insulation', no credible length or number of PVC-insulated conductors (particularly in a domestic dwelling) should have a 'low' IR, but ...
As I said, it may also be as a result of plaster drying out etc.
If you are talking about conduction through condensation/moisture, then that's a possibility - but I would still be worried if IR were as low as 10MΩ in the absence of any apparent reason to suspect that moisture might be the issue.

Kind Regards, John
 

If you need to find a tradesperson to get your job done, please try our local search below, or if you are doing it yourself you can find suppliers local to you.

Select the supplier or trade you require, enter your location to begin your search.


Are you a trade or supplier? You can create your listing free at DIYnot Local

 
Back
Top