I insulated our roof with rockwool between the rafters, up against the felt, 20 years ago. The house (original part) is 120 years old, with a tile and felt roof,The house is 3 floors, with the top floor built into the roof space. I got a council grant to do it, and a guy came round to inspect it with the comment he would be happy to see more jobs like it as most are badly done. We have no heating upstairs, and there is generally loads of ventilation around the place. Euphemistically called draughts. As far as I know there is no problem, and on the new part, the insulation is fitted behind foil backed plaster board. Again as far as I can tell there are no problems.
Is this a case of an automatic panic response to insulation, or does it only present a problem in overheated, underventilated houses?