Yes I'm being a bit cynical but realistically I don't believe my technical beliefs are far away from yours on this topic, particularly as the way the SPD has been incorporated into the installation.Much as I tend to be pretty cynical about such things myself, I doubt that it was a significant part of the reason for 'adding SPDs to the regs' - since, as we know, they never have a problem in finding excuses for creating a new amendment or edition of the regs, even in the absence of some new-fangled device for them to include! ... and, of course, they have to regularly 'update' the regs to take account changes in CENELEC.
As I've said, my personal view is that SPDs are one of those things which appeared, and is heading towards 'being required' simply because it became technologically possible to mass-produce them (and for people to make a fortune by selling and installing them), without much (if any!) serious consideration of whether or not there was actually a true need - and particularly odd for BS7671,since it's really the first rime it has included regs which have really got nothing to do with 'personal safety'.
I believe there is possibly an element of truth in Murcochat's idea that the financial side of SPD's may have usurped the technical advantage of them, especially as the unit I tested didn't show any worthy action when the voltage was slowly ramped up.

