• Looking for a smarter way to manage your heating this winter? We’ve been testing the new Aqara Radiator Thermostat W600 to see how quiet, accurate and easy it is to use around the home. Click here read our review.

Whatdo do about recordings?

Joined
27 Apr 2008
Messages
10,128
Reaction score
1,147
Country
United Kingdom
Hi, with being a long term Sky customer they are putting my monthly cost up over £20 than it was last year so I'm kicking them into touch.
We had the basic package but do like to be ableto record and binge watch series shows etc.
ALthough looking at our recording list, the majority of them are BBC based.

We have a smart TV and access to all the streaming servies we use is available on that.

I'm going to get the BRSK 500mb fibre (currently sky paying more for only 70mb).

So the crux of this is what recording device would you reccomend?

I saw that Humax are no longer doing freesat boxes, is freesat on it's way out?
Freely seems to be a replacement for freeview but I cannot record from that.
 
If you have a usb socket on your smart tv you could just use a portable hard drive. Sky used to let you use the box for “free tv” for £10 per month.
 
We have a humax freeview recorder. Mainly use it to record commercial channels and skip the adverts
 
If you have a usb socket on your smart tv you could just use a portable hard drive. Sky used to let you use the box for “free tv” for £10 per month.
They stiill do, its now about £13 but I refuse to pay them to watch freeview/freesat.
I can do that anyway, it's just the recording I want so I want to get a freeview or freesat recorder but not sure whats good now?
 
A memory stick in your tv will enable Freeview recording on most recent smart tv’s.
Have a freesat recording Humax box but rarely use as most programs we watch are available on catch up tv from the terrestrial channels.
Stream all content from all the streaming service free from web sites.
So only pay for Broadband.
 
Last edited:
Hi, with being a long term Sky customer they are putting my monthly cost up over £20 than it was last year so I'm kicking them into touch.
We had the basic package but do like to be ableto record and binge watch series shows etc.
ALthough looking at our recording list, the majority of them are BBC based.

We have a smart TV and access to all the streaming servies we use is available on that.

I'm going to get the BRSK 500mb fibre (currently sky paying more for only 70mb).

So the crux of this is what recording device would you reccomend?

I saw that Humax are no longer doing freesat boxes, is freesat on it's way out?
Freely seems to be a replacement for freeview but I cannot record from that.
i record all my tv via aerial on 3 freeveiw recorder boxes to knock out the adverts
as you have found recorder boxes are now old hat as terestial tv is old hat being phased out around 20.30 with all being via internet with freely being the option as the new frreview foremat
 
i record all my tv via aerial on 3 freeveiw recorder boxes to knock out the adverts
as you have found recorder boxes are now old hat as terestial tv is old hat being phased out around 20.30 with all being via internet with freely being the option as the new frreview foremat

3 recorders
 
A memory stick in your tv will enable Freeview recording on most recent smart tv’s.

I've been using hard drives plugged into a USB port on the back.

I suppose a memory stick would be handy if you wanted to record particular films or series and tuck them away.
 
Don’t really have much use for recording programs as so many can be accessed online.
 
I've been using hard drives plugged into a USB port on the back.

I suppose a memory stick would be handy if you wanted to record particular films or series and tuck them away.
You can get a huge amount of recordings on a 256gb memory stick .
 
Possibly slightly off topic. I occasionally use "get iplayer" to download audio and video to my laptop. There are no storage time limits/constraints. You need to use text based searches for the PID reference number, and then once you have that you can download it and keep the audio/video for as long as you want.
 
The writing is on the wall for broadcast TV via terrestrial (an aerial), and via satellite. It has been decided that internet-delivered TV is the way forward. Exact dates for the switch-off of terrestrial and satellite have not yet been set. Terrestrial is certainly not 2030 as one poster has suggested, but it is planned with in the 2030s unless there's some slippage.

The satellite switch-off is likely to happen before terrestrial. Freesat and Sky share some of the same satellite channel services, so the two things appear to have a joined fate. Sky is already pushing hard to move to an IP-only platform. New subscribers are being pushed towards Sky Stream and Sky Glass rather than the satellite receiver in Sky Q.

The idea of making recordings doesn't fit with IP TV. Any content will remain on the respective channel's servers, so if you want to watch something again then calling up a bookmark or searching again for a programme is how it will be. That's fine for mainstream stuff, but not much use if you or someone you know appears on the local TV news one night, or if some person or situation is no-longer deemed to be socially acceptable to the perpetually offended mob. On this last point, I'm concerned that we're entering an age of censorship by the backdoor, with decisions driven by the whims of public outrage through social media pressure rather than genuine concern for the moral welfare of society. Haven't we already seen the negative effects of cancel culture and social media campaigns. (Apologies for the little diversion there.)

Current terrestrial broadcast licences expire in 2034. That doesn't mean the services will be switched off in 9 years time, but it is a marker point. The key to any switch off will be in the rollout of an alternative to terrestrial. This centres on the uptake of broadband in homes where they're either too remote or the occupiers have no interest in the connected world. Convincing someone's nanna that she has to spend £20 a month on a broadband subscription on top of the licence fee just so she can continue watching Bargain Hunt is going to be an uphill battle. For this and other reasons, I can foresee the licences being extended beyond the 2034 end date.

Quite what the situation is with satellite is another question. According to figures for 2024 from GfK, Freeview (aerial TV) is consumed by 16 million homes. By comparison Freesat is viewed in 2 million UK homes. Your guess is as good as mine whether that's a small enough number for the Government to consider terminating the service and migrating viewers to Freeview or a stripped down version of Sky's Stream service. Freesat is part of the UK Government's commitment to public service broadcasting, so a decision to switch off has wider implications.

For someone moving away from Sky and still wishing to receive and record, the current 4K Freesat boxes from Arris will work with the wideband LNBs used by Sky Q, and also the quad LNBs as used by Sky+ and Sky+HD receivers. Old Humax Freesat boxes only work with the quad-type LNBs.

For recording Freeview, a USB pen drive does work in many TVs, but it has some serious limitations in a lot of cases. The biggest one is that there's only one tuner in the average TV. This means you don't have the ability to record 'the other channel'. You can watch the channel as it is being recorded. You can also be out or have the TV switched off while it is recording. What you can't do is record the football or the motor racing while someone else watches BGT or Strictly Ballroom.

The other issue is that the recordings are locked to the TV they were made on. That's not such a big deal, but what do you do when you come to swap out to a new TV? A Freeview recorder starts to look like a good idea, even if it only runs for a decade.
 
Cheers all, I cancelled sky today so I have 31 days to find a replacement.

We have a hisense TV that although it mentions a recording facility I have not yet found how to actually do this, I suspect my model cannot do it.
(I have attached a suitable sized drive or two to it).

As for Freely, yes it's being hawked as a replacement for freeview, however there are no recording facilities on it.

I think I'm going to get the BRSK 500mb service, use my own Fritz Now!" router and just make do with freely until er indoors complains that she cannot find something on the catchup streaming sites.

Anything worth watching on sky will also be available on pirate bay too lol.
 

If you need to find a tradesperson to get your job done, please try our local search below, or if you are doing it yourself you can find suppliers local to you.

Select the supplier or trade you require, enter your location to begin your search.


Are you a trade or supplier? You can create your listing free at DIYnot Local

 
Back
Top