Bathroom ceiling build up with cold void above

Joined
8 Nov 2024
Messages
47
Reaction score
2
Country
United Kingdom
Hi all,

I'm trying to install a bathroom in an upstairs bedroom. The ceiling is down and i've been trying to think through the buildup of the ceiling but would appreciate a sense check. The room is in the outrigger part of a solid walled semi, so there's an unheated loft space above that isn't used for storage or anything. The membrane has been replaced with a breathable one and there's a good breeze let's say up there. The old ceiling joists are quite twisted and uneven. I've got an extractor fitted up there to vent humidity out of the future bathroom.
1795121435806.png

The issue is that the ceiling height is not going to be great since we're raising the floor too. So for lighting I was going to try and go with downlights, but I understand that can be a bugger to do with the vapour barrier.

My thinking so far:
- PIR/rigid board between the joists, possibly with rock wool laid perpendicularly on top.
- VCL beneath the PIR flush with the underside of the joists.
- Counter-batten the ceiling from the warm side to level the joists and allow a void for the downlights.
- Moisture resistant plasterboard, either taped and jointed or skimmed.

Presumably those counter-battens need to be 50mm deep to allow for the final plasterboard screws to purchase properly,.... In which case i've eaten into the headroom even more. Most of the downlights that are 'insulation coverable' seem to only be suited to loose insulation rather than rigid board. The ceiling joists are c.100mm deep, do you think i could get away with say fitting the top 50mm with PIR and then using the rest as a ventilation gap for the lighting, somehow stapling the VCL to follow the insulation.

Thanks
 
Last edited:
I think your proposed approach is broadly sensible, and you're asking exactly the right questions. However, there are a couple of things I'd change, particularly around the position of the insulation, ventilation and vapour control layer (VCL).

The good news is that I don't think you necessarily need to sacrifice 50mm of ceiling height just to get a decent, level ceiling with recessed lighting.

There is a way of approaching this that should keep the ceiling build-up relatively shallow while still dealing properly with condensation risk.

1. The insulation arrangement
You have approximately 100mm-deep ceiling joists, with a cold, unheated loft above.

My preference would be:

  • PIR insulation between the ceiling joists.
  • Additional insulation above the joists, if the available height and roof ventilation arrangement allow it.
  • A continuous, properly sealed VCL on the warm side of the insulation.
  • A service void beneath the VCL for electrical cables and lighting.
  • Moisture-resistant plasterboard.
One important distinction: any ventilation gap needs to be on the cold side of the insulation, not between the insulation and the plasterboard.

I wouldn't deliberately leave the lower 50mm of your 100mm joists empty as a ventilation channel for the lights. That would put a ventilated space on the warm side of the insulation, which isn't what you're trying to achieve.

2. The VCL and counter-battens​

Your suggested arrangement of putting the VCL beneath the insulation is correct in principle.

I'd arrange it as follows:

  1. PIR between the joists.
  2. VCL running continuously beneath the joists, with all joints taped and sealed around the perimeter and penetrations.
  3. Counter-battens fixed beneath the VCL.
  4. Plasterboard fixed to the counter-battens.
The counter-battens give you a service void, which is particularly useful in a bathroom because you can run electrical cables and accommodate lighting without repeatedly penetrating the VCL.

Do the counter-battens need to be 50mm deep?

No, not necessarily.

You need sufficient timber depth to:

  • Take the plasterboard screws securely.
  • Allow for any unevenness in the existing joists.
  • Provide sufficient clearance for your chosen light fittings.
A 25–38mm-deep batten may be perfectly adequate, depending on the fixing arrangement and lighting specification. You can use packers to level the battens rather than automatically dropping the entire ceiling by 50mm.

3. Downlights – the bit I'd give most thought to​

I agree that recessed lights can complicate things.

There are three approaches worth considering:

Option A – Shallow LED downlights

Look at slim, fire-rated LED downlights with a suitable IP rating for their bathroom location.

Some are designed to fit into relatively shallow ceiling voids. Check their actual installation depth and whether they require clearance from insulation.

Option B – Surface-mounted LED lights

This is probably the easiest solution technically. You retain the full insulation and VCL arrangement, without cutting holes through either.

There are some very neat, low-profile LED fittings available now.

Option C – Downlights within a service void

This is probably the compromise I'd investigate first.

You could create a 38mm service void beneath the VCL and select lights specifically designed to fit within that space.

However, don't assume that a 38mm void automatically accommodates a 38mm fitting. You need to allow for the fitting body, driver, cable connections and any required clearance.

The Insulation Manufacturers Association actually recommends creating a service void beneath insulation to avoid penetrating the insulation and its vapour control layer.


4. Your proposed 50mm PIR / 50mm ventilation gap idea​

I wouldn't do this.

The problem is that the 50mm gap would be below the insulation rather than above it. It wouldn't provide the ventilation needed to protect the cold roof structure.

If you have 100mm joists, I'd be inclined to use as much of that depth as possible for insulation, subject to the roof construction and ventilation requirements.

You could then add further insulation above the joists from the loft side.

For example, a possible arrangement would be:

Illustrative ceiling cross-section

Cold loft – ventilated space

Additional insulation above joists (if appropriate)
Existing 100mm joists with PIR between
Continuous sealed VCL
25–38mm service battens / lighting void
Moisture-resistant plasterboard and finish
Conceptual arrangement, not a construction specification. Insulation thickness and roof ventilation need checking against the actual roof construction.
One important point: the breathable membrane doesn't automatically mean you can disregard roof-space ventilation. Its vapour resistance and certification matter. You need to establish whether the roof is designed as a conventionally ventilated cold roof or a breathable roof construction.



5. A couple of bathroom-specific considerations
Because this is going to be a bathroom, I'd pay particular attention to two things:

  • Extractor: Make sure it actually discharges outside, rather than into the loft. Insulate the duct in the cold loft and arrange it to avoid condensate collecting and running back towards the fan.
  • Air tightness: Bathrooms produce a lot of water vapour. Seal the VCL particularly carefully around the perimeter, cables, pipes and any other penetrations. A good extractor is important, but it doesn't replace a properly constructed ceiling.
Also, have the lighting checked for the relevant bathroom electrical zones and IP requirements.

6. A few things I'd like to clarify​

Having looked at your photograph, I'd like to understand the roof construction a little better before recommending a definitive build-up.

1. Is the new ceiling going to be horizontal or follow the roof slope?


Horizontal ceiling, with loft above

Sloping ceiling following the rafters

A mixture of both

2. Do you know what type of breathable membrane was fitted?


Modern breathable roofing membrane

Traditional bitumen felt

Not sure

3. Are the 100mm timbers definitely the ceiling joists?


Yes, 100mm ceiling joists

They are actually roof rafters

Not sure

4. Can you access the loft above to lay additional insulation?


Yes, easily accessible

Yes, but access is restricted

No

5. Are you committed to recessed downlights?


Yes, definitely want recessed lights

Prefer recessed, but open to alternatives

Happy with surface-mounted lights
Submit answers
My overall feeling: I'd concentrate on getting the insulation and VCL right first, then design the lighting void around them. I wouldn't compromise the thermal or moisture performance of the roof just to accommodate downlights.

With those five details, we can work out a sensible build-up in millimetres and see how much headroom you can realistically save.

Hope that helps.
 
Thanks, see this is my problem with AI - apart from the unfamiliarity of being complimented, i'm still no wiser as to whether that gap between the back of the plasterboard and the start of the insulation is a bad idea. It seems to refer to it as a ventilation gap, but that's not strictly the intention in respect of the moisture, it's only in terms of the void needed for the downlights and to allow heat to dissipate rather than surrounding it in insulation.
 

If you need to find a tradesperson to get your job done, please try our local search below, or if you are doing it yourself you can find suppliers local to you.

Select the supplier or trade you require, enter your location to begin your search.


Are you a trade or supplier? You can create your listing free at DIYnot Local

 
Back
Top