Chinese Consulate workers assault man in Manchester

[JohnD]

"Appears to show"

What was the result in tne court case?

And was this what you "witnessed?"

 

[Vinty]

You say a lot of things

So do you.
However i am talking from experience.

 

[Vinty]

What was the result in tne court case

It isn't illegal to pay people to protest.
So why would there be a court case.

 

[JohnD]

experience.

So you claim.

 

[transam]

All these climate change fruit cakes gluing them selves to
Infrastructure causing chaos

Perhaps we should get them chinese fellas from the consulate to deal with them as well

 

[carmanmemoranda]

It isn't illegal to pay people to protest.
So why would there be a court case.

So they weren't breaking the law?

Getting dragged into the compound and beaten up. Is that breaking the law?

 

[transam]

So they weren't breaking the law?

Getting dragged into the compound and beaten up. Is that breaking the law?

Chinese deny it

 

[carmanmemoranda]

Chinese deny it

Obviously not seen the camera footage

 

[Vinty]

So they weren't breaking the law?

Getting dragged into the compound and beaten up. Is that breaking the law?

The alleged victim had a bit of a scratch under his eye, hardly merits the term "beaten up".
If the embassy officials did drag him into the compound, then they are guilty of something i suppose.
On the other hand, waving placards with images of the Chinese PM with a rope around his neck was bound to upset those people inside the embassy.
Free speech is all very well and everyone should have the right to protest but when you do things which are intended to antagonise and provoke your opponents, then there should be limits.

 

[Vinty]

So you claim.

I signed the official secrets act years ago, unfortunately this restricts me for life from commenting further.

 

[carmanmemoranda]

The alleged victim had a bit of a scratch under his eye, hardly merits the term "beaten up".
If the embassy officials did drag him into the compound, then they are guilty of something i suppose.
On the other hand, waving placards with images of the Chinese PM with a rope around his neck was bound to upset those people inside the embassy.
Free speech is all very well and everyone should have the right to protest but when you do things which are intended to antagonise and provoke your opponents, then there should be limits.

So have we decided who broke the laws ?

And who was protesting legally ?

 

[transam]

Obviously not seen the camera footage

No I have not

 

[transam]

In it fair

Foreigners come to the UK to protest about what is happening thousands of miles away in there own country

Cause chaos
Waste tax payers money due to the UK having to foot the bill for policing

Cause a diplomatic incident

All about some thing that has nowt to do with us

Kick em all out imo they can take there pointless protest to China

 

[carmanmemoranda]

In it fair

Foreigners come to the UK to protest about what is happening thousands of miles away in there own country

Cause chaos
Waste tax payers money due to the UK having to foot the bill for policing

Cause a diplomatic incident

All about some thing that has nowt to do with us

Kick em all out imo they can take there pointless protest to China

We invited them over.

They are not illegal immigrants

 

[Vinty]

And who was protesting legally ?

The protest was 100% legal, there is no doubt about that, the protesters themselves seemed to be genuine, unfortunately these type of protests can be infiltrated by others with an agenda of disruption and violence, they are skilled whipping up emotions in order to advance their political aims.