Dry Ridge Weak Points

Joined
17 Apr 2009
Messages
602
Reaction score
9
Location
Sussex
Country
United Kingdom
Is it my imagination or do these very supermodern new "systems" create numerous weak points for water ingress that were not in the original mortared joints "system !".

x1ridge.jpg
 
I've always wondered about that screw going through the plastic piece and into the ridge how watertight it is.
 
It is Not Dry ... actually.
Look at the following and you can see that the "system" is no longer a continuous barrier against rain but actually permits rain straight in under those tiles and then organises the dripping onto the membrane underneath which the clay tiles sit on no doubt cutting into it.
If "wind uplift" is the issue, the removal of mortar reduces the weight of the structure by at least 50% giving it a nice chance to fly off, especially as mortar no longer holds the sides down.
If the tiles are meant to be "mechancially fixed" ... to what?
To each other with plastic clips?
It thought the idea was to fix them to the ridge !
Are there not Victorian or prehistoric mortar ridges still working after centuries?
Or is the idea to put as much plastic everywhere just like into my new 501s Stretch?
Cost?
Oh the Dry Ridge is Double the price is it ....,
"Ah I See !" (quoting the rather nice flower girl from Palmeira Sq)

dry 2.jpg
 
properly fitted dry ridge holds up against storm weather much better than mortar mate. the screw and plastic union just clamp the tile down onto the ridge batten, the actual weatherproofing comes from the breathable roll underneath that sticks down to the tile profiles with butyl tape. mortar looks neater to some people but first hard frost we get it cracks and you're up on a ladder replacing blown bedding, whereas dry systems can flex in the wind without budging.
 
Looks to me that there are numerous holes between the ridges ... and the water goes straight into those holes and under the ridge tiles ... is that alright? Are they secretly just gushing onto the membrane underneath? And these pegs that stick up ... quite a few weakpoints isn't it. I hope they are all SS. I see they have a 10yr guarantee on roofing superstore.
And what happens when a tile fails?
The tile is no longer mortared to anything.
And if it falls off the entire ridge fails.
Tell me again ... who it was that came up with this ?

I often think the same about those "irons" that are placed at the bottom of ridges, often see them brown and crispy.
Did nobody think to put the fixings "under" the tile .... no?
> I am doing my own roof that's all I'm saying.

ridge 4.jpg
 

If you need to find a tradesperson to get your job done, please try our local search below, or if you are doing it yourself you can find suppliers local to you.

Select the supplier or trade you require, enter your location to begin your search.


Are you a trade or supplier? You can create your listing free at DIYnot Local

 
Back
Top