Horstmann HRT4 ASR-ZW

Joined
29 Apr 2013
Messages
49
Reaction score
3
Location
Yorkshire
Country
United Kingdom
Afternoon, Just removed the above receiver to decorate. Noticed that the earth wire from the boiler is connected to terminal 2 (com) for some reason. Was curious as to why it is not connected to the earth terminal - see pictures and wiring diagram. Any information would be much
IMG_20230709_143221.jpg
IMG_20230709_143328.jpg
Screenshot_20230712-070103.png
appreciated?
 
Sponsored Links
Because it’s being used as the switch output (on one of your photos), so the common/live in, which is bad practice as it’s more commonly used as the cpc/earth connector. It would be prudent to either renew the wiring or at least apply some brown sleeving/insulation tape if 230vac switching to indicate it’s being used as a live wire.
 
Thanks a lot for this - hate not understanding - I will put some brown sleeve on!
 
  • Thanks
Reactions: CBW
Sponsored Links
In reality it should be 5 core flex. 1 core (Green/Yellow) for the earthwire and only the earthwire and nothing else even if you oversleeve it.
Even if the earthwire is never actually used because there is no earth terminal.
 
In reality it should be 5 core flex. 1 core (Green/Yellow) for the earthwire and only the earthwire and nothing else even if you oversleeve it.
Even if the earthwire is never actually used because there is no earth terminal.
The earth wire (cpc) should be earthed even if the device does not require an earth. In this case, earth at the origin.
 
Thanks everyone. Think I'll sleeve it for now and change it to 5 core flex when next get the boiler serviced and panel is open.
 
  • Thanks
Reactions: CBW
That's what happens when plumbers do electrical wiring......
When I was working for a large manufacturing company, we bought a new large control panel from a specialist firm, all the potentiometers were wired in three core flex with the earth used as a live cable, albeit reduced voltage
 
When I was working for a large manufacturing company, we bought a new large control panel from a specialist firm, all the potentiometers were wired in three core flex with the earth used as a live cable, albeit reduced voltage
Then it was/is not "the earth".

This is the same as people calling a wire "neutral" just because it is black or blue.
 
I know no one likes it but bear in mind it has only very recently actually been prohibited with flexible cable.
I must have missed this - pending my having my BBB to hand, can you tell me about this 'recent prohibition'?

Kind Regards, John
 
Reported on the forum. I can't find it now. I presume the latest amendment.

OR

If I dreamed it, then there is no problem with the OP's wiring.
 
Reported on the forum. I can't find it now. I presume the latest amendment.
Reunited with BBB.

The forum was correct. 544.4.2 now prohibits oversleeving of G/Y conductors in multicore cables, as well as G/Y singles. I must say that I was unaware of this, but I suppose that it is reasonably sensible.

Kind Regards, John
 
Last edited:
  • Thanks
Reactions: CBW

DIYnot Local

Staff member

If you need to find a tradesperson to get your job done, please try our local search below, or if you are doing it yourself you can find suppliers local to you.

Select the supplier or trade you require, enter your location to begin your search.


Are you a trade or supplier? You can create your listing free at DIYnot Local

 
Sponsored Links
Back
Top