He was doubtless protective of her as a female colleague. I have no sympathy for her assailants, they packed a powerful punch, possibly amateur boxers. I cannot see the PC being prosecuted.
Manchester airport assault
- Thread starter motorbiking
- Start date
As already mentioned, I haven't followed the trial.
I can see that if you thought three strangers were attacking you from behind, you might be terrified. Especially after you had just been involved in another fight. But once you realised they were actually police officers, that might change things. Did the defence try to explain why he continued.
Last edited:
So Motorbiking, what do you think the sentance will be, no chrage or time in jail?
Andy
Andy
I've just read this in the Manchester paper:
What if that was the one juror who would have cleared them.
Also, the judge has asked them to continue deliberating, but has now said he will accept a majority verdict from ten jurors.
What if that was the one juror who would have cleared them.
Also, the judge has asked them to continue deliberating, but has now said he will accept a majority verdict from ten jurors.
IT would have been 11 to 1 then
Yes, that seems to make sense.
Are there any scenarios where it would make a difference.
- Joined
- 31 May 2016
- Messages
- 24,770
- Reaction score
- 5,336
- Country
you answered your own question
- Joined
- 7 Sep 2022
- Messages
- 4,353
- Reaction score
- 1,244
- Country
I've only your paraphrase of it above, but it seems a weak argument looking at the CCTV footage; there is a considerable delay and inaction from the guy who was "grabbed" before he starts throwing punches.
If you've just head butted someone, then you're grabbed from behind and are "terrified for your life", you don't turn around, see that it's three police officers, then start a fight because you think they're gonna knife you on the spot. As an argument it would have been more believable if he'd immediately kicked/thrown backwards, turned with elbow at striking height, maybe thrown a fist then seen it's the police and not the big, ugly, knife wielding brother of the guy he just assaulted and stopped at that point with hands up rather than continuing to resist arrest
His adjacent mate was well aware of the police presence ahead of them even touching him; if he didn't say "look out, it's the rozzers" I'd think it very unusual. That he then chose to join the fight rather than subdue it diminishes the self defence argument further in my view
Last edited:
That's my take, as well.
- Joined
- 31 May 2016
- Messages
- 24,770
- Reaction score
- 5,336
- Country
It's interesting that the original offence - the alleged head butt in Starbucks, has't been pursued. I wonder if the CPS are holding it back.
Hopefully they are, just in case
No actual evidence about tommy or exactly what happened hence why people hanging back .
Manchester clear video evidence of the scum bags attacking people doing their job and an innocent family sitting having a coffee .
But then that doesnt suit your thought processes does it
It certainly sends mixed messages, though.
