I think you're right to question the quote, because there are two quite different issues being mixed together here:
- Does the electrical work in the extension need to comply with current regulations?
- Does every part of the extension need a completely new electrical circuit, with all the associated costs?
The answer to the first is yes. The answer to the second is absolutely not necessarily.
There is also an important distinction between having electrical work tested and certified by an electrician and having an EICR carried out after the work is finished.
I wouldn't automatically accept the electrician's suggestion that you need new circuits everywhere without first understanding why.
1. The rules in England are actually quite favourable to your argument
Under Part P of the Building Regulations, the following work is notifiable:
- Installing a completely new electrical circuit.
- Replacing the consumer unit.
- Altering an existing circuit in a special location, such as the zones around a bath or shower.
However, adding sockets to an existing circuit outside those special locations is generally
non-notifiable work.
Importantly, this includes kitchens in England. The rules changed in April 2013, so adding sockets to an existing kitchen circuit does not automatically require Building Control notification.
The Planning Portal confirms this distinction.
Planning Portal+1
Applied to your extension:
| Area | Potential approach |
|---|
| Extended kitchen | Extend the existing kitchen circuit, subject to capacity and suitability |
| Existing bedroom extension | Retain existing circuit and wiring where appropriate |
| New bedroom | Extend an existing suitable socket circuit |
| Garage | Potentially extend an existing circuit, depending on its intended use and electrical loading |
So, in principle, your suggestion of adding a couple of sockets to existing circuits is perfectly reasonable.
There is no blanket requirement to install a separate circuit for every room.
2. Does everything have to be brought up to current regulations?
This is another important point.
The government's Approved Document P makes it clear that when an existing electrical installation is extended or altered,
only the new work has to meet current standards.
You don't automatically have to bring the entire 1970s bungalow electrical installation up to modern standards.
There are exceptions:
- If the existing installation is unsafe and the new work would make that worse.
- If the existing installation cannot safely support the additional electrical load.
- If existing earthing, bonding or protective arrangements are inadequate for the new work.
The electrician must assess the existing installation before connecting new work to it.
But that doesn't mean a perfectly serviceable existing circuit needs ripping out simply because you're extending a room.
GOV.UK+1
3. Can you have an EICR afterwards instead?
This is where I would be a little careful.
An EICR (Electrical Installation Condition Report) is designed to assess the condition of an existing electrical installation.
It isn't a replacement for the appropriate certification of newly installed electrical work.
There are different certificates for different jobs:
- Electrical Installation Certificate (EIC): For new circuits and new installations.
- Minor Electrical Installation Works Certificate (MEIWC): For additions or alterations to existing circuits that don't involve new circuits.
- EICR: For assessing the condition of an existing installation.
The IET is quite clear about the distinction.
IET Wiring Regulations+1
So, if your electrician installs a new circuit, you can't simply avoid the appropriate certification by asking somebody else to carry out an EICR afterwards.
However, if you extend existing circuits, you may only need minor works certification for those alterations.
That could make a considerable difference to the cost.
4. What about getting Building Control to agree to your approach?
I would absolutely speak to your Building Control inspector before committing to the electrician's proposal.
However, there's an important distinction: Building Control agreeing with your proposed arrangement doesn't remove the requirement for the correct electrical testing and certification.
If you use an electrician who isn't registered with a competent person scheme, notifiable work needs the appropriate Building Control or third-party certification route. This should be arranged before work starts.
If the work is non-notifiable, it doesn't need a separate Part P notification, although it still needs to comply with the relevant electrical safety requirements.
Planning Portal+1
5. What I'd be asking your electrician
Before accepting the quote, I'd ask him to break down exactly what he's proposing.
In particular:
- Why does the extended kitchen need a new circuit if the existing kitchen circuit is suitable?
- Can the new bedroom sockets be supplied by extending an existing socket circuit?
- Can the extended bedroom retain its existing electrical installation?
- Does the garage genuinely need a dedicated circuit, or can it be supplied from an existing circuit?
- Is there anything about the existing consumer unit, RCD protection, earthing or bonding that prevents the existing circuits being extended?
Your metal consumer unit being relatively modern is encouraging, but it doesn't automatically mean the existing circuits are suitable for additional loads.
I'd also ask whether he's proposing new circuits because they're genuinely necessary from an electrical design perspective, or simply because that's his preferred way of doing the installation.
Those are two very different things.
My recommendation
I wouldn't dismiss the electrician's advice, but equally I wouldn't agree to a substantial amount of additional electrical work without understanding the justification.
Your proposed approach is potentially perfectly legitimate:
- Retain existing circuits where suitable.
- Extend those circuits into the new areas where appropriate.
- Install dedicated circuits only where the electrical design and anticipated loads justify them.
- Have the new work properly inspected, tested and certified.
- Obtain an EIC for new circuits and minor works certificates for appropriate alterations to existing circuits.
One final thing: I would specifically ask Building Control whether they are happy with the proposed electrical certification arrangements before the extension is completed. Don't leave this until the end.
You can find the official guidance here:
Planning Portal – Electrical Building Regulations.
One thing I'd be interested to know
When you say the consumer unit has mostly separate circuits, do you mean you have:
- A separate ring circuit for the existing kitchen sockets?
- A separate ring circuit for the existing bedroom sockets?
- A separate lighting circuit?
And is the new bedroom going to be immediately adjacent to the existing bedroom?
The reason I ask is that, depending on the existing circuit layout, you could potentially extend the kitchen ring into the kitchen extension and extend an existing bedroom ring into the new bedroom without installing additional circuits.
That is where I suspect you might be able to make some worthwhile savings without compromising safety.