I know this is an old thread, but I'm in the same boat, so to speak, and find that the blanking plugs as mentioned above aren't the right size - they're too small. I know, I've just bought one. They seem to be for the inlet hole, which is a much smaller diameter. It's something to do with calling a physical hole which is actually approx ¾" diameter, a ½" one because its to take a ½" pipe fitting! The OPs problem is that the physical hole he wants a new washer for is 1" diameter, and the rules of plumbing calls that a ¾" hole 'cos it takes a ¾" pipe fitting. The Flomaster blanking plugs are only for the ½" hole, being ¾" diameter and I' ve found that it's far too small to effectively and safely block the 1" diameter hole, that is used for the overflow pipe. I think that the OP would have to buy a new internal overflow pipe, as that comes with the elusively correct size of washer. I've just googled, and you have to search for ¾ “ BSP washer or blanking plug.