Trump v Zelenskyy

I am still trying to think through what happened yesterday. Not so much about Ukraine, but the much bigger picture. Most importantly, where does it leave us.
Who knows, it’s more about damage limitation but the state visit should help
Clearly, Trump cannot be trusted. That was brought home to me for real. Is Trump going to reorganise the world on the hemisphere principle which I posted about earlier. Many experts are now thinking that is possible.
He might be planning to split the Uk from Europe so he has a base for his troops, air force and weapons when he pulls out or is kicked out of Europe.
Did the American people want a wholesale change in foreign policy.
Most Americans don’t have a concept of the world outside their continent still less foreign policy, except for and wall and migration from Central America
If America pals up with Russia, how does that affect all the weapon systems we and the rest of Europe rely on. The uncertainty is a huge problem for me. Would a future Democratic president then change things. How can we plan on this basis.
We have to work with Europe and try to keep in with the USA
Are Germany going to commit to proper armed forces.
Yes, and they will be massively efficient but Pootin wants that do he can justify his aggression
Should we re-join the EU for economic security.
Should never have left
There is a lot to think about!
 
JD was confrontational from the start, Trump kicked off after Zelensky said 'we're getting it, but you have a big ocean, if you stop helping us, you'll be getting it too' or words to that effect, which Trump read as a threat, well, it was a threat and Zelensky is hardly in a position to make threats to the POTUS.

But it was never going to be cordial, I doubt Donald has forgotten that Zelensky helped Biden impeach Trump back in 2019 by not dishing the dirt on Hunter and Burisma oil.

Trump did start yelling about Hunter Biden at one point near the end. It wasn't clear to me how it was related. It's pretty sad if that is one of the drivers here.

I don't think Zelensky was threatening Trump. How could he? I don't know what point he was going to make, because he got cut off. Maybe that when the USA has been isolationist in the past they have had to get involved in the end to sort out World Wars.
 
JD was confrontational from the start, Trump kicked off after Zelensky said 'we're getting it, but you have a big ocean, if you stop helping us, you'll be getting it too' or words to that effect, which Trump read as a threat, well, it was a threat and Zelensky is hardly in a position to make threats to the POTUS.

But it was never going to be cordial, I doubt Donald has forgotten that Zelensky helped Biden impeach Trump back in 2019 by not dishing the dirt on Hunter and Burisma oil.
Which Trump mentioned himself a week or so back i.e. we have a big ocean between us.

If it was a setup of sorts, I have a sneaking suspicion it could backfire.
 
Yes, and they will be massively efficient but Pootin wants that do he can justify his aggression

The dynamic between Germany and Russia is very complex and something I don't fully understand.
 
I think Zelenskyy was close to doing that, he looked really p**sed.

There was one moment near the end when Trump was saying how much Putin respected Trump, and Zelensky made the slightest raise of his eyebrows. I thought that was a pretty stupid thing to do. I hope Trump doesn't see it.
 
20250301_215751.jpg
 
The dynamic between Germany and Russia is very complex and something I don't fully understand.
Russsia stokes up division in tne west to weaken its perceived opponents, iincluding germany but it might end up biting off more than it can chew as she rearms.
 
Trump did start yelling about Hunter Biden at one point near the end. It wasn't clear to me how it was related. It's pretty sad if that is one of the drivers here.

It may be sad it's a driver but it is quite a big one, Zelensky helped Biden launch the impeachment against Trump by keeping schtum on Hunters and by default his dads involvement in Burisma Oil (Ukraine), it quite a bid deal, It was dismissed by the court but only after Biden won the election.


I don't think Zelensky was threatening Trump. How could he? I don't know what point he was going to make, because he got cut off. Maybe that when the USA has been isolationist in the past they have had to get involved in the end to sort out World Wars.

'We're going through it now, you're OK, you have a big ocean, but if you don't back our security, you're going to go through that as well' (or words to that effect)
That was when Trump kicked off and said something along the lines of don't tell us what we're going to go through next.

It was a threat, it was cheeky, it was a minor leader of a minor eastern european country attempting to lay down the law to the leader of the free world.

**** me, did you really expect Trump to crumble at a threat like that, do you expect Trump to crumble because 'europe' will come to the rescue and steal his thunder, really?

The best we can hope for, is that after Zelensky has met with every european leader, who by now are s******g themselves that they might have to step into the breach, is that they tell him to stop being a knob, apologise profusely to Donald, ask for another meeting and if you're lucky to be granted one, at least have the ******g decency to turn up in a suit and tie.
 
I read in a couple of places that when Trump was just a property thug in New York decades ago, the Russians tried to recruit him. I passed it off when I saw it, but it makes a certain amount of sense now.
He said Zelensky started the war, Zelensky was a dictator, and a couple of other things I thought were't consistent with his general mantra that Z should just have realised he was never going to win so should have "dealt" his way out of it.
Those two statements were straight from the Russian propaganda. Nobody in the west believes them. He shut off the second when prompted but why say it? Just to seed doubt in the West? Were they lifted from the intro to Putin's case? Russia has recruited plenty of key US figures since WW2.

--

The worst I saw in that interview, was that T, and Vance especially wanted Z to grovel. The initial question about wearing a suit looked like a plant.
T and V have forgotten that the invasion was wrong, and it was Putin.
The US has a policy since Truman, post war 2,
That:
"it must be the policy of the United States to support free peoples who are resisting attempted subjugation by armed minorities or by outside pressures."[4] Truman contended that because totalitarian regimes coerced free peoples, they automatically represented a threat to international peace and the national security of the United States."
Problem 1, Truman was a Democrat and Trump chooses not to follow it. T would cite various conflicts including Korea, Vietnam, Afghan and others where an ordinary American might agree that the US should have kept out.
Let's face it, give an American a map and a pin to find those countries, or Ukraine for that matter...

Biden supported the Truman Doctrine, not least by giving (yes 84% giving, not lending ) materiel to Z.
Trump wants payback so constructed a mechanism incredibly advantageous to the US as a sham "opportunity" for Z, which would do nothing to stop Russia carrying on as before until Ukraine is gone.

Vance was an a-hole. Z has been thanking the US at every opportunity until into Trumps tenure, for what was Truman's policy, but V appears to have disregarded all of that and now sees Z as someone who owes the US and is therefore to fall over and be fleeced because he's in a weak position.


What I thought Z was going to say when T shouted him down was that T would feel bad in future when he sees Putin's expansion continue.
With hindsight, Z might have made T/V pause and give an answer on that - who did the big wrong here, was it Putin yes or no? But I don't think T cares either.

--

Europe has spent too long fannying about over its own politics since WW2 and is in a similarly weak position. If it wants to support Z, it will have to spend baby spend. That will have to be buying US arms at inflated "compensational" prices, because Europe doesn't have enough output.
If Europe builds new missile factories specifically to kill Russians, P might choose to bomb them, the case is easy.

Way forward? Kick the can down the road to a large extent. Resist in Ukraine with US largely defensive weapons bought by an Allied fund, with no more aggresive scope than has been provided so far. Ukraine will still be lost in the end, unless things change in Russia.
(Canada, Japan and others could contribute)
But meanwhile, build up Euro forces such that if any of those bordering states is invaded, there can be severe costs to Russia sufficient to deter.
Economically, Russia is weak, unless (?) supported by China.
That does mean a new Euro defence alliance. Maybe that goes /anti-Putin/anti-Kim Jong Un, or just Europe - hoping that the next US administrations are different, (Trump only got ~50%) with better Euro contributions to Nato. Also, Europe is still taking gas in large volume from Russia. That needs to be wound right down to reduce dollars going east. Imports of LNG gas from the US are also part of the picture.

What with? Drones. Thousands/millions of them. I've been bangin on about that for years. P will make them too, so ours will have to be better.
 
Last edited:
But meanwhile, build up Euro forces such that if any of those bordering states is invaded, there can be severe costs to Russia sufficient to deter.
And what do you envisage the UK role in that should be?

After all, we are according to brexiteers not European...

Camoron started the ball rolling by choosing to hold a referendum (because of a far right threat) which has caused the destabilisation of Europe, which was the aim of poo tin in the first place...

And now instead of halting the far right, they are gaining popularity across the EU...

So if the UK isn't in Europe, where is it?

Does it lean towards the mess of the US because it can't afford not to?

There was a term used by the Afrikaans towards those who couldn't really choose between Britain and South Africa...

'Soutpiel' - which literally translated means 'salt prick'.
One foot in Britain and one foot in South Africa, with your dick in the ocean...

That is where the UK now finds itself as regards Europe and the US, and it ain't going to end well !

What with? Drones. Thousands/millions of them. I've been bangin on about that for years. P will make them too, so ours will have to be better.
The UK is totally broke, so how is the country going to pay for these 'better drones'?

And where is the infrastructure going to suddenly appear from overnight to manufacture them?

Let alone train up enough people to design/build/operate them...

Although maybe the trainees could become the trainers - Ukranian veterans teaching the UK.

But think on this. Our armed forces are shrinking, and in order to do this it would require more recruitment...

Given that apart from the completely stupid or desperate, it is fairly obvious to most that there is an even bigger conflict coming...

And who would sign up for that, or who would want their children to do so?
 
Last edited:
You Trump is thin skinned petulant child that bears a grudge for years.

There’s no evidence that there was anything corrupt about Hunter Bidens appointment at Burisma oil
absolute comedy gold why do you think sleepy joe pardoned him right back to 2014 what crimes do you think it was he thought his son had committed back then
 
It sums zalenskey up when his own ambassador looks at him and puts her head into her hands obviously thinking oh ffs here he goes .
As for him being set up it was the Ukrainians who pushed for the televised oval room meeting against the advice of US ukraine envoy General Kellogg who has been doing the negotiations and is no Trump lap dog
 
It sums zalenskey up when his own ambassador looks at him and puts her head into her hands obviously thinking oh ffs here he goes .
As for him being set up it was the Ukrainians who pushed for the televised oval room meeting against the advice of US ukraine envoy General Kellogg who has been doing the negotiations and is no Trump lap dog
Wasnt General Kellogg a Cereal killer?
 
Back
Top