Multinational forced to pay some tax

[Mottie]

So she has benefited from other peoples investment.

So you are saying she should pay because other people have invested? Did she ask or encourage them to? You idiot.

 

[SirGalahad]

So you are saying she should pay because other people have invested? Did she ask or encourage them to? You idiot.

So you admit that the price of the home has increased without her doing anything -because other people have invested and she is benefiting from that.

Lol you really just shot your own argument.

 

[SirGalahad]

It's always this mythical old lady living in big old house that gets trotted out - ask the old lady if she would like a functioning healthcare system to go with her big old house.

 

[Mottie]

I had to check what forum I was in for a moment - I thought I’d accidentally stumbled onto the communism forum. Maybe JohnD and Gally live in council houses?

 

[Mottie]

So you admit that the price of the home has increased without her doing anything

Haven’t JohnD’s stocks and shares increased without him doing anything? Do you approve of those who have spare cash investing in stocks and shares to make more money? Stocks and shares ISA's where you pay no tax on the dividends and profits they generate for you doing fùck all? Where has JohnD gone in this thread - he can tell us of his tax avoidance shenanigans. Or maybe not.

 

[BlueLoo]

Fool.

You seem quite fond of that thought.

 

[Mottie]

Where has JohnD gone in this thread

Oh, you've both gone. Goodnight. Sleep tight, don’t let the capitalists bite.

 

[fillyboy]

She doesnt have to downsize she can pay the tax due and stay there.

Again are you dumb?

The capital is better allocated to those who can get better use of the larger house.

**** me, and you're calling other people dumb.

 

[JohnD]

Sounds like JohnD and Gally just don't like 'millionaires'.

Oh mottie you are silly. You're just trying to think of excuses for disliking a fairer tax system.

 

[JohnD]

Haven’t JohnD’s stocks and shares increased without him doing anything? Do you approve of those who have spare cash investing in stocks and shares to make more money? Stocks and shares ISA's where you pay no tax on the dividends and profits they generate for you doing fùck all? Where has JohnD gone in this thread - he can tell us of his tax avoidance shenanigans. Or maybe not.

Your short-term memory is even worse than I thought. You can't remember from one page to the next.

It's time you got a diagnosis.

Have you sold your London business premises yet?

 

[fillyboy]

Have you sold your London business premises yet?

L’erba del vicino è sempre più verde.

 

[Mottie]

Have you sold your London business premises yet?

No. I thought I might help someone with no capital behind them and rent it out. What about you, have you sold your place in Greenock or were you just renting?

 

[motorbiking]

So you are saying she should pay because other people have invested? Did she ask or encourage them to? You idiot.

What about the little old lady who lives in the south east in a modest 4 bed house. Why should she downsize when the little old lady living next to noseall has a luxury 5 bed mansion worth a quarter of the value.

 

[motorbiking]

Some of them might.

every employee earning in the top 1% will be paying around half their income in tax. Not some, all. 28% of all taxes. Some 1/2 a million people. The top 10% pay 60% of all income tax.

so next time you moan about how little tax the ”wealthy” pay. Maybe think about your own contribution.

 

[Notch7]

So you are saying she should pay because other people have invested? Did she ask or encourage them to? You idiot.

The problem is that there are millions of people that bought many years ago, their houses have massively increased in value - which they’ve done nothing to generate that.

And now we have millions of people who can’t afford to buy and and are stuck in over priced rentals.



You might want to turn this into a tribal capitalist vs socialist argument - but in order to,solve a problem, it needs understanding.

Maybe you could think about a solution, then you will start to appreciate problem