New Boiler Technology

Status
Not open for further replies.
Whilst we have the current range of boilers and they are very efficient and all that good stuff, they don't seem to promise the longevity that the old boilers did. ..or even the reliability. Good news for CORGI guys of course but bad news for the consumer
started the post off.......
It is a pity no one else has come in because to you it may look "personal".*
But I say again, educate me..** link or show me the figures that prove why to fit my 72% boiler is virtually a crime in this country..

It uses too much fuel and the emissions are poor too.

"You are saying modern boilers brake down a lot and provided no figures"

I did provide figures, the Sedbuk table, after your figure that older boilers ran as low as 50% efficiency!

That is efficiency not breaking down. Got it?

You keep saying "30 years ago" " back in the 1970's" What world are you in ? My example is to compare a 1990 boiler with little or no working parts, linked to a system with at most two (expensive) working parts, pump and diverter valve, with the best A boiler.

I mean everything: cold tank, F&E tank, ballcock, cylinder, zone valves, stats, boiler, pump etc, EVERYTHING. The system. In a combi only the rads are outside the boiler case, everything is put inside the case: zone valve, pump, stats, etc. Anything goes wrong inside a combi and its the boiler. If a pump goes in an old system the boiler is pointed to. If the ballcock goes it is not the boiler. Think SYSTEM, then look at the picture.

You see my world is where even the old cheap boilers, at 72%, lasted 20 years ! (very good for the environment)

Look again!!! Read what I write.

The thread is about the environment and longevity of modern boilers, you make a statement to say that a "quality boiler" will outlast the older Ideal Classic type, now that is nonsense. At what cost? that is the whole point of the thread, your modern boiler will last twenty years, but at what cost? your new boiler will not cost more to service/repair ? , it will not need new pcb's, or a fan or heatstats or diverter valves or pumps?

I know of many quality makes that are 20 years old with no parts added in that time. Old Vaillants, Viessmann (well 15 years old in their case), Archie Kidd, etc. I take you have never experienced a modern quality boiler.

Just take time to read the first hundred posts (about boilers) on this forum, they prove my point, dozens and dozens of complaints about faulty pcb's

You are spouting tripe. Obviously statistics was not your subject.

* You dont know me or my background but you say "The trouble with the likes of you is that you just don't understand boilers, systems and controls in any depth having superficial knowledge" and then you say do not take it personal? ...... in your words...what nonsense.

An honest opinion.

I like an honest debate or thread with anyone but, as I think you might say..., it's people like you who read the manufacturers efficiency tables and are blind to what is going on in the real world, the world where even the best boilers do not last without expensive repairs,

Figures please! Stop making things up.

where a £60 pump is 'adapted' to fit a combi and now costs £180, where there are now two pcb boards fitted to boilers at £100 each and when the pump or any other part leaks they may need replacing. How is this energy efficient?

You are talking through your uneducated rear end again. You are implying all boilers need a pcb, pump, etc every few years. Total tripe.

<snip the rest of the drivel>
 
Sponsored Links
//www.diynot.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=124478
//www.diynot.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=90413
//www.diynot.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=124198
//www.diynot.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=124284
//www.diynot.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=111521
//www.diynot.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=124276
//www.diynot.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=124002

Just a 30 second glimpse at problems and mostly negative feedback associated with the modern boilers from this forum, (there are others)

http://www.guardian.co.uk/money/2005/apr/02/consumerissues.jobsandmoney

http://www.which.co.uk/reports_and_...ng_contracts_essential_guide_574_120700_9.jsp

http://community.channel4.com/eve/forums/a/tpc/f/6026044741/m/3270057966 I wonder how many people suffered with this efficient boiler?
http://www.screwfix.com/talk/thread.jspa?threadID=29100&start=0&tstart=0

Yes there are many examples of reliable modern boilers, however..
...in my opinion, too many negative comments about branded and less well known boilers since 2005.

I mean everything: cold tank, F&E tank, ballcock, cylinder, zone valves, stats, boiler, pump etc, EVERYTHING. The system. In a combi only the rads are outside the boiler case, everything is put inside the case: zone valve, pump, stats, etc. Anything goes wrong inside a combi and its the boiler. If a pump goes in an old system the boiler is pointed to. If the ballcock goes it is not the boiler. Think SYSTEM, then look at the picture.

..as i stated earlier, out of the nine parts you list from the old system only the pump, zone valve & gas valve on the boiler ever caused a problem, the rest cost a few pounds to repair. ( even with todays copper price a dhw cylinder costs only slightly more than a pump for some combis) Also when these parts did fail they very rarely affected anything else. You get a pump leaking on a combi, and as the countless posts prove, the likely hood is the pcb or other parts get damaged also.

Unlike the good 'doctor' who wants us all to believe the modern boiler is the worlds salvation I am just asking for some up to date figures or positive comments to prove this technology is the right way forward.


Because you don't know or understand. Do you drive around in morris Minor as well

No .... I still run a Sinclair C5.

why not use the forum to advise and educate, rather than personal petty comments? Just a thought.
 
Sponsored Links
anjme, have you started yet to think there are some people not worth talking to?
 
Did a quick drivel, sorry goggle. Found a fantastic new hot water & heat source.
Its old technology from india and made by Hindustani, the best model is the elephantian.
Runs on anything recyclable and delivers huge amounts of hot water day and night also comes with built in shower outlet. The heating system uses mobile modules called mounds. These come in random sizes and outputs and can be moved around to suit.
A corgi cert or g3 cert is not req to install, which is good news.
When the mounds are drained of heat they are recyled through the
gar-den which is an optional extra but a useful means of obtaining extra fuel for primary heat source. No fancy timers req the unit automatically senses daylight and starts working. Some models come with gas production outllets as well, insert a tube into the arris and connect to modified cooker. The unit is bigger than a vailant store and not easy to wall mount. Reckon its the way of the future.
 
All Dr Drivel doeas is spout rubbish, he simply trawls the web and cuts and paste, whenever is has been asked to prove his theory or his claims, he goes very quiet, I am still waiting to see photos of the whole solar roof he claims to of installed.
 
Unlike the good 'doctor' who wants us all to believe the modern boiler is the worlds salvation I am just asking for some up to date figures or positive comments to prove this technology is the right way forward.

You are so dumb it is beyond belief. He comes up with tripe about boilers with no figures to back it up. He can't distinguish modern combis and what they contain to basic cast-iron rubbish 30 years old. He can't see that boilers are cheap these days with a plethora of makes and many of them low quality with prices to suit - they are super cheap expendable items, so you get what you pay for. He can't even name a high quality boiler and keeps carping on that all boilers go through a pcb ever few years. He has little to no reasoning with no analytical skills whatsoever continually arming waving about how bad new boilers are. He seems to think that all old cast-iron boilers never went wrong - I must have imagined fixing all those then.

IN short an uneducated oaf.
 

DIYnot Local

Staff member

If you need to find a tradesperson to get your job done, please try our local search below, or if you are doing it yourself you can find suppliers local to you.

Select the supplier or trade you require, enter your location to begin your search.


Are you a trade or supplier? You can create your listing free at DIYnot Local

 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Sponsored Links
Back
Top