cabinet door hanging problem

[Reeves2k2]

I have 2 cabinet doors to hang just bog standard 22mm mdf panel

The first went on fine the second however is giving me grief

I'm using those flush hinges that don't need recesses.

The problem is the problem door once hung springs back when you close it
the hinges feel a bit tight as the door closes the other door is fine and shuts properly

The frame is square and plum I've checked and double checked that and I've also tried shimming the hinges but I can't seem to get it quite right

Can someone offer some advise

Thanks

 

[kbdiy]

Have you checked the door itself isn't slightly bowed?

Some pictures might help too.

 

[Reeves2k2]

Have you checked the door itself isn't slightly bowed?

Some pictures might help too.

Just checked door and it seems fine.
It was only cut at the timber yard yesterday and been kept flat. I have the rest of the sheet which is ok too

I'll see what I can do picture wise

 

[Reeves2k2]

Managed to sort it after scratching my head all day

Must have been a bad/bent hinge as new hinge with a slight mm or so packing sorted it

All I can think is either the hinge was bad to start with or I bent it slightly initially tightening it up

 

[big-all]

my suggestion would have been to loosen both hinges on the door about 2 turns and watch how the hinges react this allows a hinge off line to try and lift or drop and even twist a bit

 

[Reeves2k2]

my suggestion would have been to loosen both hinges on the door about 2 turns and watch how the hinges react this allows a hinge off line to try and lift or drop and even twist a bit

That's exactly what I did in the end and I noticed the bottom hinge seemed like it wanted to move with the door when it got about an inch away from closing causing it to spring back